Year One

3 out of 5 stars

Time Out says

3 out of 5 stars

An old-school gagfest in the spirit of History of the World, Harold Ramis’s Year One—about a pair of wandering Neanderthals turned biblical buffoons—feels a little prehistoric itself. But with age comes wisdom, at least in terms of making an enjoyably dumb comedy: If a joke about whacking a cavegirl on the head doesn’t quite work, speed on to slapstick involving foreskin removal. Obviously, realism isn’t the goal here; don’t be too concerned with period accuracy. People know Old Testament fables, and can also laugh at prisoners being hung upside down in jails, a truly unfortunate position to be in if your bladder is full.

You won’t quite piss yourself as thoroughly as does poor Michael Cera, but for all its unevenness, the film is blessed by its lead actors. Jack Black, playing an inept boar hunter, continues to draw dividends from his crazy-eyed-visionary thing, while his character’s buddy, Oh, flourishes in Cera’s neuroticism. (The latter lashes out at another “self-hating gatherer.”) Other cameos are less effective: Oliver Platt’s mincing Sodomite—he really lives in Sodom—strays cringingly toward sissy. But mainly, Ramis, the old pro behind Caddyshack, is on comfortable ground, even if that ground is Apatow-produced and ultimately a touch too civilized.—Joshua Rothkopf

Now playing.

More new Film reviews



Release details

Cast and crew