[category]
[title]
Review
A dedicated pizzeria from Chef Alex Sanchez and restaurateur Mallyeka Watsa was perhaps only a matter of time. The pizzas at their flagship restaurant, Americano, have long enjoyed a cult following of their own, so this feels like a rather natural next chapter. Here, Alex brings his take on the traditional American pizza parlour to life, drawing on the flavours, sights and memories of his West Coast childhood.
A buzzing commercial area filled with heritage buildings in South Bombay plays host to this new instalment, which makes a virtue of its heritage setting, retaining the original flooring, exposed rafters and architectural character rather than tearing them up. The split-level space has two distinct moods: downstairs, an industrial-meets-contemporary pizzeria centred around a long stainless-steel counter and open kitchen; upstairs, a cosier, more intimate bistro-like setting. Window-side seating peeks out onto the street, while a full bar and standing ledges along the kitchen offer an easy perch for those dropping in for a spritz and a quick bite. For the most engaging experience, though, pull up a seat at the pizza counter and watch the team stretch, dress and bake each pie.
This lively, compact room, complete with a full bar, feels as suited to an after-work aperitivo as it does to a pizza dinner. It’s hardly the place for a hushed conversation, though, and the constant bustle is a fair indication of the waitlist. Tables may require some planning, but walk-ins can always try their luck at the counter.
The menu extends beyond its 15 pizzas, bringing together American pizzeria staples and dishes that show Alex’s more chef-driven side. The mozzarella sticks are a case in point. Crisp outside, molten within, they took me straight back to the string cheese children love in the US and still consider a very respectable quick snack as adults, me included. Alex told me the team spent months getting the cheese and breadcrumb combination right. It captures the thought behind the menu. The skinny fries, almost straw-like and crunchy, are another easy win with the house ranch, creamy with onion, garlic and dill. The chopped iceberg wedge, with its blue cheese dressing, brings a classic Californian steakhouse feel to the table.
But the biggest reason to stop by is that Alex has developed a dough distinct from the wood-fired style at Americano: airy and fermented, with a crisp exterior, chewy, pillowy crumb and enough structure to hold its toppings. The longer bake produces a crust of impeccable texture that doesn't overwhelm its toppings. The Trenton Cheese is the thin-and-crispy number, with sauce on top, pecorino and garlic oil; the others have a more noticeable, airy edge.
The Meatza, topped with house meatballs, bacon, pepperoni and mozzarella, gets the balance right. There's plenty of meat, but the pizza doesn't buckle under its toppings. The Artichoke Spesh, with artichoke hearts, spinach and garlic cream, is rich and mellow, while the Kejriwal is a charming nod to Bombay: mozzarella, Amul cheese, aged cheddar, green chilli and a soft-cooked egg at the centre. Alex cuts this into squares, a clever detail that helps keep the yolk intact.
Alex doesn't pile on toppings for effect; the ingredients are just right and enough to satiate. A flight of chilli condiments, from crunchy nut-chilli oil to pickled chillies and house hot sauce, lets diners add their own finishing touch. Even the leftovers reheated beautifully, with the crust crisping up again the next day.
Dessert is no afterthought and has a little American food history, with a generous scoop of nostalgia. Alex has spent considerable time perfecting the Fior di Latte soft serve, getting its texture and melting point just right so it holds its swirl in those old-school steel, footed cups. The Tin Roof, with chocolate fudge and roasted salted peanuts, is a nostalgic crowd-pleaser. The Butterscotch Pudding is more personal: a childhood memory of the pudding packets his mother would dissolve in milk and leave to set in the fridge, now elevated with salted caramel and Chantilly. The menu's 'Ode to Bradley, Claudia and Nancy' tips its hat to chefs Bradley Ogden, Claudia Fleming and Nancy Silverton, whose work inspired Alex to take this humble pudding further. Then there's the Affogato Radio Ball, his take on Philadelphia's nostalgic combination of water ice and ice cream, here reimagined with espresso Italian ice, soft serve and mascarpone mousse.
The drinks are expectedly delicious and well picked. I liked the potent White Negroni, but the Amalfi Spritz is the one I would return for: lemon-led, made with the house’s Amalfi lemon crema, bergamot, basil and bubbles. The soda fountain, with old-school flavours such as Orange Dream, adds another perky note. Don't miss the cherry Coke; it's Alex's favourite!
Pizzeria Americano is glitzy, yet already feels like the neighbourhood joint you want to keep coming back to. The cacophony inside mirrors the street outside, but there's a warm glow to the place that makes settling in for an entire evening of indulgence all too easy. Think of it as a full-blown cheat-meal extravaganza, and one you won't regret. Tables may be coveted and privacy scarce, but neither should put you off. Alex has taken a deeply personal slice of American nostalgia and given it a distinctly Mumbai address.
Time Out tip: If you walk in at 5.30pm, the chances of getting a table are promising. Anything later and it’s cloudy with a chance of meatballs.
Discover Time Out original video
Â