Time Out says
The top-notch cast keep calm and carry on, but this TV remake is a waste of everyone’s time
If you grew up in the ’70s or '80s you’ll remember reruns of Dad’s Army on the ABC. Now – why oh why? – someone has decided that what we really, really need is a big screen version. Like 40 years (and several generations of sitcoms) never happened, this pointless remake of the wartime comedy opens with a platoon of old men being chased round a field by a bull.
These venerable duffers are Home Guard volunteers, the men who will protect Britain with their DIY weapons if the Germans invade. The action hots up with the arrival of Catherine Zeta-Jones as a foxy journalist on assignment from Lady magazine, while at the same time MI5 get intelligence of a Nazi spy infiltrating the town.
To be fair, the cast is best of British. Toby Jones is comedy gold as Captain Mainwaring, the ridiculous and pompous bank manager in charge of the platoon. Bill Nighy does a lot of debonair eyebrow arching as Sergeant Wilson, his suave second in command, and Michael Gambon is adorable as the dithery, dotty Private Godfrey. But the wink-wink double entendres are painful.
There is an interesting-ish side-plot involving a women’s auxiliary platoon and two sharp-as-dagger-tips Miss Marples who have everything sussed from the start. Going down the all-female route (like the new Ghostbusters) would have been something. But even granddad has moved on from teatime comedy gags about jam roly-poly.
Cast and crew