Book review: Silence Once Begun by Jesse Ball

Something that begins as an inventive, satisfying crime story finds itself in philosophically rich territory.



Add +

Photographer: Lauren Spinelli

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>4/5

By Jesse Ball. Pantheon, $24.

Though it’s a work of fiction, Jesse Ball’s new novel convincingly utilizes true-crime devices. The premise: In late-1970s Japan, a man named Oda Sotatsu signed a confession claiming responsibility for the disappearances of numerous elderly citizens, then refused to speak in his own defense, despite no evidence connecting him to the crime. In Silence Once Begun, a newly divorced writer named Jesse Ball interviews figures on the case’s periphery, seeking a greater understanding of Sotatsu’s reticence.

Silence incorporates a vast array of styles: Ball’s musings, interview transcripts, other characters’ accounts of the case and even a few Sebaldian photographs. Throughout, there are many questions about both what is said and what is left unsaid; motivation, memory and reliability all come under scrutiny. Though its structure and language reflect an intellectual game play, the novel’s haunting, final paragraphs form a demonstration of Ball’s authorial thesis, applying notions about unknowability and community behavior on a grander scale. It shifts the book’s stakes: What had been a taut crime story stands revealed as something much more ominous.

Users say


Books events calendar

  1. The Moth StorySLAM!

    Ten stories. Three teams of judges. One winner. Th...

  2. #365FeministSelfie...

    Unconvinced of the self-absorption of selfies, a g...

  3. The Moth StorySLAM!

    Tonight’s theme is “saved.”

Subscribe to Time Out New York on Spotify for playlists and recommendations from our Music team.

Check out New York's best restaurants, hottest street style, cool apartments and more.