Review: Astray by Emma Donoghue
These stories, which take their cues from historical events and extant documents, fare best when Donoghue lets her imagination wander
Wed Nov 28 2012
Photograph: Jessica Lin
Time Out Ratings<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5
By Emma Donoghue. Little, Brown; $26.
Whether the traumatized child at the center of Room or the humanized figures in the folktales of Kissing the Witch, Emma Donoghue’s characters seem thoroughly unique and alive. Her new collection, Astray, strives for much the same life, spanning continents and centuries, sometimes focusing on individuals on the periphery of historical events. Her protagonists range from a child in 1839 to the humble keeper of an elephant in the London Zoo.
Donoghue produced these stories with the aid of authentic accounts and documents, and she follows each tale with a short contextual note. It’s telling that “Snowblind,” the story of two prospectors in over their heads in the Yukon, relies the least on extant documents but stands out as one of the best in the book. Suspenseful tales of deception and intrigue, such as “The Widow’s Cruse” or “The Body Swap,” are also among the collection’s highlights. But “Last Supper at Brown’s,” about a plan to murder a loathsome Texas slave owner, suffers when its supporting backstory is revealed; the events described might lead readers to believe an even more fascinating work was possible.
That said, Astray ends on a particularly moving note. “What Remains” examines the lives of sculptors Frances Loring and Florence Wyle. In a nursing home, the pair contrast their salad days with the end of their lives, as Loring struggles with dementia. It’s at once a powerful work of fiction and an evocation of stories that are worth researching further. As the collection’s best blend of fiction and history, it reminds the reader how potent a combination of the two can be.