The Mermaid Oyster Bar

Critics' pick
1/5
Photograph: Lizz Kuehl

Mermaid Oyster Bar

2/5
Photograph: Lizz Kuehl

Mermaid Oyster Bar

3/5
Photograph: Lizz Kuehl

Mermaid Oyster Bar

4/5
Photograph: Lizz Kuehl

Mermaid Oyster Bar

5/5
Photograph: Lizz Kuehl

Mermaid Oyster Bar

West Village
Book a table
OpenTable

Book now

When times are tough, restaurateurs tend to lean on reliable formulas to stay afloat. That seems to be the case with the Mermaid Oyster Bar, from Danny Abrams and Cindy Smith. This third (and best), oyster-heavy location of Abrams’s popular New-England seafood eatery, the Mermaid Inn, has replaced their elegant but ill-fated bistro, Smith’s, which closed late last year. The couple swiftly refurbished the space, convincingly transforming a formerly sultry dining room into a bright fish shack with wainscoting and whitewashed walls. While the name suggests a mostly uncooked menu, the bill of fare is balanced between the curated raw bar—16 oysters complemented by the usual clams, mussels, crab, shrimp cocktail and lobster—and plated dishes that salute seafood favorites, ranging from greaseless clam strips with a tangy tartar sauce to a robust shellfish-enriched lobster bisque. With the help of our pleasant waiter, it was fun choosing among the exclusively North American oysters, split on the menu into East and West Coast categories; each type is accompanied by intriguing vocabulary like lettucy, zesty salinity and deep cup. We weren’t disappointed by the spectrum of flavor—from a musky Hog Island to the pungent Pemaquid. Entres, like a clean and meaty grilled Idaho trout with herbaceous salsa verde, were as simple as they were rewarding. And local tap beers, such as the hoppy Captain Lawrence Freshchester Pale Ale, were laid-back yet suitable matches for the dishes. Per the usual Mermaid Inn tradition, the meal ended with a free cup of rich chocolate pudding and a Fortune Teller fish, a formula that hasn’t gotten old. Sometimes there are advantages to playing it safe.—TONY

See more Restaurant reviews

Venue name: The Mermaid Oyster Bar
Contact:
Address: 79 MacDougal St
New York

Cross street: between Bleecker and W Houston Sts
Opening hours: Mon–Thu 5:30–11pm; Fri, Sat 5:30–11:30pm; Sun 5–10pm
Transport: Subway: A, C, E, B, D, F, V to W 4th St
Price: Average main course: $19. AmEx, Disc, MC, V
LiveReviews|0
3 people listening