Made famous by the eponymous movie, Mystic Pizza has been serving up slices the same way since 1973. Fans of the film are delighted to see the restaurant has a striking similarity to the one in the movie, though due to a size and timing issue, it was not shot there. All of the pies are made with a "secret recipe" sauce. Just like in the movie, it has never been revealed to outsiders. A second location opened in North Stonington, but you’ll want to visit the original locale in the beautiful seaside town of Mystic for a more authentic experience.