Nymphomaniac: Part Two

Film, Drama
0 Love It
Save it
Nymphomaniac: Part Two

Danish director Lars Von Trier’s anti-raunchy sexual epic about one hyper-promiscuous woman assumes a darker shade in this second, final episode. Our anti-heroine Joe (first Stacy Martin, later Charlotte Gainsbourg) now recounts to her one-man audience (Stellan Skarsgård) how, in middle age, she came to lose all sense of sexual pleasure and find a sadder joy in masochism, threat and violence. While much of the sex in the first film came across as a childish game, here it feels like self-imposed punishment as Joe submits to the whips of an S&M master (Jamie Bell) and the dangerous thrills of sex with strangers, abandoning her sleeping child at night.

It’s now, too, that Von Trier starts to bring together loose strands and build theme upon theme. If he directed ‘Les Misérables’, it would look like this: time-hopping, expansive, episodic, crude, jolty, anarchic, self-depreciating but also unashamedly melodramatic by the time it reaches its conclusion. Joe is on a tragic trajectory and can’t escape her past: that past, we learn, is Jérome (Shia LaBeouf), her first lover and later her boss, partner, father of her child and ultimately her nemesis. The pair meet and re-meet with all the subtlety of dodgy opera. Von Trier even makes a joke of this by having Gainsbourg admit in her confession-narration to Skarsgård that coincidences in her tale are rife. It’s this self-mockery that stops ‘Nymphomaniac’ being overly grim and reminds you of the puppetmaster behind it all. We’re never far from Von Trier, and both Skarsgård and Gainsbourg appear to offer different versions of the author himself.

Von Trier’s pooling of an international cast (Bell, LaBeouf, Christian Slater, Jean-Marc Barr and others), all speaking English in continental European settings, has become a filmmaking style all of its own. You either run with it or laugh. Roughly, this is supposed to be England (only the currency gives it away; LaBeouf’s wonky accent is presumably the decoy) and equally roughly, between Part One and Part Two, we move from the 1970s to now. But rough is the word: you don’t come to a Von Trier film for social realism and a cast-iron sense of time and place. You come for raw honesty; provocation; contradictions; flights of fancy. You also come for brave, committed turns from actresses. And both newcomer Martin and old-hand Gainsbourg anchor these two films with performances you can’t take your eyes off; they’re the calm eyes of Von Trier’s storm.

Is there any sign here of a chastened Von Trier after the ‘I’m a Nazi’ scandal that engulfed him at Cannes in 2011? You only have to hear Skarsgård’s character musing on how non-active paedophiles ‘deserve a medal’ or see Gainsbourg sandwiched between two African immigrants with hard-ons to know the answer. He might not have been in control of the edit of this version of his film (the uncut version will emerge later), but the frank, unflinching and playful two-part ‘Nymphomaniac’ couldn’t have been made by anyone else.

Read the review of Nymphomaniac: Part One

By: Dave Calhoun


Release details

Rated: 18
Release date: Saturday February 22 2014
Duration: 124 mins

Cast and crew

Director: Lars von Trier
Screenwriter: Lars von Trier
Cast: Charlotte Gainsbourg
Stellan Skarsgard
Shia LaBeouf
Jamie Bell

Average User Rating

4.5 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:1
  • 4 star:1
  • 3 star:0
  • 2 star:0
  • 1 star:0
1 person listening

Nymphomaniac: Part Two is in many ways a harder-hitting film than part one. It really comes into its own at the very end, when the character Joe (played by Charlotte Gainsbourg) makes a damning indictment of the different way she would have been treated by society had she done everything she’s narrated but instead been born a man – she would feel far less punished and castigated. The film therefore concludes with a striking, and unexpected, feminist tone  and is all the better for it.

After the controversial marketing campaign, nobody would decide to watch Lars von Trier’s four-hour epic without expecting plenty of between-the-sheets action. Yet the X-rated scenes serve neither to titillate, nor to teach a moral lesson. The Danish director used the story of a sex addict – impeccably played by both Charlotte Gainsbourg and Stacy Martin – to explore not just sexuality, but a much wider spectre of human desires.
This soulful film (or two films, if you prefer) about soulless sex is also a display of von Trier’s erudition. The multiplicity of cultural references, ranging from Beethoven to
Michael Haneke, could easily delve into artsy-fartsy pretentiousness. However, what ultimately saves the movie is its self-referential humour and emotional honesty.
Nymphomaniac can amaze you or shock you, amuse or annoy. One thing is for sure: no one in the audience will be left indifferent.