Film, Drama
5 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars
(3user reviews)
Photo: Netflix

Time Out says

5 out of 5 stars

Alfonso Cuarón dives into his Mexican boyhood with this absorbingly rich tribute to the resilient women who raised him.

With his white-knuckle sci-fi thriller ‘Gravity’, Mexican auteur Alfonso Cuarón extracted an intimate character study from the vastness of outer space. Now he goes in reverse: In his deeply personal black and white marvel ‘Roma’, Cuarón – a director of erotic road-trips (‘Y Tu Mamá También’), dystopian thrillers (Children of Men) and ‘The Prisoner of Azkaban’, the finest entry in the Harry Potter series – unhurriedly observes the smallest parts first, before expanding to gradually reveal the social and political canvas of 1970s Mexico City. It’s the city where he grew up – in a middle-class neighborhood called Roma. A sober and autobiographical elegy about his childhood and the women who raised him (one hardworking live-in maid in particular), ‘Roma’ coalesces out of episodic recollections, digitally filmed with a crisp, grain-free appearance for unsentimental visual conviction.

The domestic helper at the heart of the story is the gentle-natured Cleo (exceptionally talented newcomer Yalitza Aparicio), who works for the affectionate but occasionally livid Sofia (Marina de Tavira, terrific and understated) and the rest of her family. Through transfixing long takes that capture the monotony of Cleo’s chores, Cuarón dotingly honors Cleo’s unsung rituals (just as Chantal Akerman did in her 1975 feminist classic ‘Jeanne Dielman, 23 Commerce Quay, 1080 Brussels’): cleaning, looking after Sofia’s lively four children whom she loves like her own, interacting with her best friend and co-worker Adela (Nancy García García), going on movie dates with her self-absorbed, martial-arts-loving boyfriend, and so on.

At first, the lives of Cleo and Sofia run on parallel yet detached lines, save for regular household interactions and cosy evenings jointly spent in front of the TV, where Cleo is treated as part of the family (sometimes to an awkward degree). But when a marital separation and an unwanted pregnancy upset the lives of the two women from different ranks of the social order, their fates cross paths in a real sense for the first time. And, as the world around their newfound female camaraderie slowly crumbles – with earthquakes, wildfires, violent political demonstrations and one especially traumatic episode of unimaginable grief, filmed with unwavering empathy – ‘Roma’s physical and emotional scope grows and deepens.

The cumulative result of Cuarón’s inquisitive lens (he is also the cinematographer) is an astounding interplay of foreground and background, with artistry that measures up to the meticulously choreographed films of ‘Tokyo Story’s Yasujirô Ozu, and political content akin to Italian neorealist classics like ‘Rome, Open City’. Throughout ‘Roma’, Cuarón demands that you savour each of his frames carefully, eyeballing the corners of the screen for small but significant thematic details intensified by a special kind of surround sound that furthers the film’s immersive, life-like nature. In his personal journey down memory lane (occasionally lightened by humorous anecdotes about a family dog and an extra-wide Ford Galaxie that barely fits in the driveway), Cuarón retroactively examines Cleo’s life in respectful tribute, not guilt-ridden apology. A richly textured masterpiece, ‘Roma’ is cinema at its purest and most human.

By: Tomris Laffly



Release details

Release date:
Wednesday November 21 2018
135 mins

Cast and crew

Alfonso Cuarón
Alfonso Cuarón
Yalitza Aparicio
Marina de Tavira
Nancy García García

Users say (3)

4 out of 5 stars

Average User Rating

3.7 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:1
  • 4 star:1
  • 3 star:0
  • 2 star:1
  • 1 star:0
2 people listening


Watched this wonderful monochrome film on my TV screen, courtesy of Netflix. No choice really as its cinema releases were almost non-existent and Netflix wishes for cinematic credibility but, understandably,subscribers to its online business.

OK, it is a stunningly superb film and broke all the rules by winning a whole bunch of bouquets, including top Academy Awards, normally conservative and often American mainstream orientated.

The movie is semi-autobiographical, based on writer, director, and cinematographer Alfonso Cuaron’s ‘70s boyhood in the Colonia Roma district of Mexico City.

It loosely covers an affluent middle-class doctor’s family ups and downs but largely seen through the eyes of their faithful servant, Cleo, who loves them and their children.

Apart from the scenes in the family apartment and the poo-strewn entrance, thanks to Borras the dog, every external frame is a mini-masterpiece of construction and detail.

It is a turbulent time in Mexico and a background of street rioting accompany the many family problems covered sensitively by this great director.

My regret is that I didn’t see it in the context of a proper cinema screen. If I ever get the chance I will be there post haste.

Roma isn't an immediate film, it's not an in-yer-face attention grabber, apart from the wonderful B&W cinematography which demands being seen on the big screen. However its riches are revealed on reflection especially on the life of the domestic at its centre and her pregnancy, then the middle-class mother forging a life when her professor husband leaves her. Plenty of  atmosphere and drama from their life events plus the backgound of social change for women and in protest. Let Roma sink in and it will reward you. 


Incredibly over-rated film. Great Black & White Cinematography, but so painfully stagnant. There is a great deal of beautifully photographic dog crap (no joke), painful car parking, and Mexican street riots. It may be a very personal film for Alfonso Cuaron, but for me it was an irritating indulgence.