The Monuments Men

Film, Action and adventure
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • 2 out of 5 stars
(2user reviews)
0 Love It
Save it
The Monuments Men

What price art? Actor-writer-director George Clooney’s true-life WWII adventure – a frustrating tonal mishmash – puts the question up front, as curator and conservationist Frank Stokes (Clooney) lays it all out for President Roosevelt: Hitler and his cronies have stolen tons of the great works (Picasso, Vermeer, Van Eyck), and it’s imperative to retrieve them. ‘If you destroy an entire generation of people’s culture, it’s as if they never existed,’ Stokes says to a skeptical FDR, who’s more concerned with flesh and blood than he is with oil on canvas. Still, the President permits Stokes to convene a ragtag team of operatives to salvage what they can as US forces push into Europe from Normandy.

You might think you’re watching a knockabout war comedy like the Bill Murray-starrer ‘Stripes’ (1981) as opposed to something more serious or visceral like ‘Saving Private Ryan’, as the group gathers for a broadly comic basic-training sequence. Here are the out-of-shape Ugly Americans (Bill Murray, John Goodman and Bob Balaban). There is the Englishman (Hugh Bonneville) tempted by drink; the Frenchman (Jean Dujardin) with the slyly salacious grin; and the green German expat (Dimitri Leonidas), who proves himself a battlefield asset. And, finally, comes an especially bland Matt Damon, as an art restorer trying to woo a resistance fighter (Cate Blanchett, doing her Katharine Hepburn in ‘The Aviator’ with a Teutonic burr).

Things don’t exactly improve once the action shifts entirely to European soil. Ostensibly funny interludes like Murray and Balaban’s culture-clash encounter with a rogue SS soldier bump uneasily against rank sentimental scenes, such as a remember-home montage cringingly scored to ‘Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas’.

Yet Clooney occasionally shows a surer hand: he gets great work from Bonneville (now best known from ‘Downton Abbey’) – notably in an emotionally charged scene revolving around Michelangelo’s ‘Madonna of Bruges’ – and has a fine monologue himself, in which Stokes dresses down a high-ranking German commander (a moving encapsulation of the American spirit at its best). You wish that same sober confidence extended to the rest of the film, which is otherwise content to be another slipshod and banal, if always watchable, Hollywood co-opting of history.

By: Keith Uhlich


Release details

Rated: 12A
Release date: Friday February 14 2014
Duration: 118 mins

Cast and crew

Director: George Clooney
Screenwriter: George Clooney, Grant Heslov
Cast: George Clooney
Matt Damon
Cate Blanchett
John Goodman
Bill Murray
Hugh Bonneville
Bob Balaban
Jean Dujardin
1 person listening

Mark Kermode on BBC News channel was very critical of Clooney's heavy-handed, and patronising storytelling. From what he said, Clooney goes out of his way to explain the story and motives several times and then, just in case you're not very bright, goes to do so all over again, and again. Not that I was ever a Clooney fan, Kermode's comments were enough to ensure I didn't waste the price of a ticket.

Very fragmented film. The script didn't seem to allow any of the talented actors to really develop their characters. Good story but you really wanted to feel the camaraderie between these men and it never really happened