American Doctor
Photograph: Conic | ‘American Doctor’

Review

American Doctor

4 out of 5 stars
Three US surgeons head into the war zone of Gaza in this damning and tearful documentary
  • Film
  • Recommended
Phil de Semlyen
Advertising

Time Out says

Harrowing and heartbreaking, this righteously angry documentary follows three doctors from the US and into the ruins of Palestine to lay bare American complicity in the horrors of the Israel-Gaza war.

It’s a really tough watch and not always a hopeful one. Consciously so. One of the doctors, Jewish American orthopedic surgeon Dr Mark Perlmutter, sits down with director Poh Si Teng at the outset and insists that there be no pixellating of casualties or corpses in the film’s depiction of ‘mass casualties events’ – and the Malaysian journalist-turned-filmmaker obliges. ‘You’re not doing the victims a service by not showing that,’ the doctor points out. ‘This is what my tax dollars did.’

There are many moments when you’ll find yourself praying for pixels. Children’s broken bodies, carried in a seemingly endless stream into Nasser hospital, are an overwhelming sight as Teng takes her camera into the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis in the spring of 2025. Her footage of the rubble-strewn wasteland that is present-day Gaza, almost equally so. How anyone can exist in this apocalyptic cityscape is a miracle in itself; how the hospital continues to function without medicine and equipment is a moving testament to the dedication of staff who are never sidelined by the film’s focus on the visiting surgeons. A ceasefire is in effect but the concussion of distant bombs land like jump shocks.

The concussion of distant bombs land like jump shocks

American Doctor explores the other role the ardent, personable Perlmutter and his two surgeon colleagues, cool-headed Palestinian-American surgeon Thaer Ahmad and dryly funny Pakistani-American surgeon Feroze Sidhwa, take on: as TV talking heads playing witness to what they’ve experienced. Israeli claims that Palestinian hospitals sit above Hamas tunnel networks, and are thus legitimate targets, are laughed at. But the death of 1700 medical professionals in the region – and the film’s devastating coda – show how seriously they should be taken. 

Peng, who spent $150,000 of her own money to make the film, brings a journalistic eye to follow the story back to America. The campaigning Ahmad disappears into a dead-end of Congressional disinterest as he gets brushed off by a string of US senators. And Perlmutter’s awareness that, as a white face, he can say things others can’t, is two-edged. Sidhwa notes that his US media appearances can backfire at the first mention of Zionism.

An increasingly fatalistic presence, Sidhwa’s despair over Gaza’s future is a heartrending note in a film full of them. But following on from two stunning documentaries about the war in Palestine, NAZA and The Voice of Hind Rajab, he’s a magnetic presence in a film that keeps the story alive in gripping fashion.

In UK and Ireland cinemas Fri Nov 20.

Cast and crew

  • Director:Poh Si Teng
Advertising
Latest news