Time Out says
Banned Iranian director Jafar Panahi is back with another brilliant filmed-in-secret film
With his extraordinary 2011 documentary ‘This Is Not a Film’ Iranian director Jafar Panahi tackled his house arrest under the repressive Iranian government. (Legend has it that the doc was smuggled out of Iran on a hard drive baked in a cake.) Now he’s made another masterful, multi-faceted feature under similarly draconian conditions. ‘Closed Curtain’ begins with an absolutely stunning long shot looking through the barred window of a seaside home. A car pulls up, and two men get out. Only one of them (co-director Kambuzia Partovi) enters the house, where he unzips a bag and lets out his pet dog (a scene-stealer), to scamper around.
The man’s first order of business is to block every window with all-obscuring black curtains. His subsequent actions and a grim TV news report reveal that he is a writer who’s come to this secluded spot to get away from authorities who are massacring dogs countrywide. The first 20 minutes are nearly silent he goes through a variety of tasks (jotting down some ideas on a pad, shaving his head, preparing a litter box for his pooch). Then a mysterious woman (Maryam Moqadam) and her brother (Hadi Saeedi) appear, at which point the seemingly simple, straightforward narrative begins to fracture in increasingly astonishing ways.
‘Closed Curtain’ touches on similar meta-artistic themes as ‘This Is Not a Film’. Panahi once again appears as a version of himself, and his entrance is breathtaking in the way it both shatters and reconfigures the story we thought we were watching. This is the tale of a man – the writer – who lives so completely with his muses and characters that he slips between reality and fantasy without an anchor to hold him. He’s not even necessarily played by the same person from scene to scene: identity is one of this bracing movie’s most malleable facets. The journey is often challenging, but the rewards – heady, emotional, provocative and invigorating – are endless.
Cast and crew