You Can See Everything
DR | You Can See Everything

Review

You Can See Everything

5 out of 5 stars
Has Nathan Fielder met his match in this hypnotically brilliant documentary?
  • Film
  • Recommended
Phil de Semlyen
Advertising

Time Out says

In this extraordinary, uncomfortably intimate documentary, deadpan Canadian genius Nathan Fielder (The Rehearsal, Nathan For You) takes on his greatest challenge yet: convicted Theranos fraudster Elizabeth Holmes and her devoted bro-coded husband Billy Evans.

Somewhere within the celebrity house-share set-up, in which Fielder, co-director Lance Oppenheim (Primetime) and their small crew essentially move into the couple’s San Diego beach house for several weeks, lurks the truth of what happened when Holmes’ tech company Theranos folded and she was left to face an 11-year jail sentence for fraud. Just don’t expect anyone to agree on what it is. 

The first half of this three-hour battle of wills interrogates what happened at Theranos, whose claim to have invented a machine that could conduct multiple simultaneous blood tests was proven to be fraudulent. Here, it helps to have read journalist John Carreyrou’s book on the subject, Bad Blood, which is forensic in a way Fielder doesn’t try to match. Or to have watched Apple TV’s drama The Dropout, which You Can See Everything weaves cleverly into its own knottier narrative. Because Holmes is still the persuasive figure who convinced preeminent people to invest in her fugazi product in the first place. She takes refuge in semantics to claim that she only promised that Theranos’s machine could do different tests, not that it would. Fielder responds with a typically situationist approach, sitting her down to watch Abbott and Costello’s ‘Who’s On Third?’ sketch to show her how meaning can be misread. She doesn’t get that either. Could one of the twists be that she’s an AI? 

Banksy couldn’t come up with a piece of art as provocative

Banksy couldn’t come up with a piece of art as provocative and unsettling. What plays out can be interpreted in a dozen different ways, depending on whether you see Holmes as a misunderstood ingénue paying a heavy price for a few innocent mistakes or an arch manipulator who invites Fielder into a world that’s still wrapped around her finger. Just because it’s smaller now – and will get smaller still when she goes to prison in the middle of the film – it doesn’t make the sense of trespassing into an alternate reality less unnerving. Evans is loyal to a fault, parroting the same lines, incapable of questioning anything Holmes says or does. When she’s jailed, he becomes a more malign presence, tweeting aggressively from her account without permission and instigating his own business venture. She sanguinely accepts his actions. It’s a level of toxic co-dependence that leaves Fielder stupified. 

It’s rare for a filmmaker to get this level of access – one shot of Evans in the shower is jaw-dropping – and least of all to a couple as vilified as this. And Fielder, whose docu-reality TV stunts are wildly unpredictable, seems like the last person you’d want sniffing about. So why, wonders the impish provocateur, has he been granted this gift? Money? The chance to reshape the narrative around Holmes? ‘Why would I deceive you?’ says Holmes, rocking her baby while staring at an uncomfortably close Fielder. ‘I have no reason to do that.’ It’s the most obvious lie in the film. 

In UK and Ireland cinemas now.

Advertising
Latest news