Easy-to-please kids will grin and bear a new Winnie the Pooh adventure, but the magic is somewhat dissipated.
Fulfilling humankind’s urgent need for cuddly stuffed bears in the marmalade-sweet wake of Paddington 2, Disney’s live-action-animation hybrid Christopher Robin—starring the hunny-loving Pooh—is big-hearted yet unexciting. While the newly imagined adventures of the grown-up Christopher (Ewan McGregor, a long way from Trainspotting) and his amiable childhood pals from Hundred Acre Wood place journeyman director Marc Forster straight back into enchanting Finding Neverland territory, this mid-20th-century tale doesn’t quite summon the same magical, childlike wonder.
Still, there is ample sweetness here for especially young kids and enough nostalgia for adult devotees of A. A. Milne’s beloved stories. Channeling Hook’s workaholic ex-Peter Pan, Christopher unhappily cancels his countryside travel plans with his loving wife Evelyn (Hayley Atwell) and precocious daughter Madeline (Bronte Carmichael), to toil overtime for his notoriously brutal employer, Winslow Luggage. Unexpectedly reuniting with the ever-hungry Winnie and the rest of the lovable clan over a weekend (sarcastically gloomy Eeyore, enthusiastic Tigger and the fearful Piglet, among them), Christopher remembers life’s simple pleasures and rekindles his youthful spirit. He learns an especially important lesson about family when Madeline teams up with the loyal critters to save her dad’s job by delivering him a misplaced briefcase.
Startlingly basic for a film jointly written by team that includes brainy indie auteur Alex Ross Perry, Spotlight’s Tom McCarthy and Hidden Figures co-writer Allison Schroeder, Christopher Robin doesn’t set up a substantial-enough conflict: Conclusive morals get force-fed into the narrative. Despite Jon Brion and Geogff Zanelli’s fairytale-esque score and Jennifer Williams’s elaborate production design that intricately details postwar London, Forster’s film feels tame in our sophisticated era of Inside Out and Toy Story 3, two superior films about parting with childhood. A well-played political message about economic equality responsibly caps off the fable, but Pooh’s luxurious yet outdated philosophy about "doing nothing to achieve something" sticks out like a heffalump in the room.
Cast and crew