Time Out says
Broad strokes will leave you feeling shafted in a film that redefines "mining disaster."
Chile’s 2010 mining disaster—and the thrilling rescue of all 33 men trapped underground—played out on a globally televised stage in front of an estimated 1 billion viewers. Far be it for any movie to try to duplicate those numbers (much less a suspenseful climax), but Patricia Riggen’s dumb-as-dirt dramatization does a particularly awkward job of it, favoring several miners with TV-ready tics (the angry guy, the Elvis fanatic, etc.) and ladling on late composer James Horner’s most jaunty and aggressive score.
Having the cast speak English is understandable (though still a mistake), but worse is the film’s naked grab for star heat with its central trio of ridiculous performances. Antonio Banderas brings squinty-eyed heroism to the role of “Super Mario” Sepúlveda, the trapped miner who becomes the group's de facto leader, yet he’s on more solid ground than Juliette Binoche as a feisty Chilean protestor (yep) or Gabriel Byrne as a brilliant Chilean engineer (yep). If we could unearth these guys from theirliving tomb, how hard is it to find nonwhite actors to play real people?
The 33 makes shameless lunges at religious imagery via ghostly auras and this-is-my-flesh apportioning of daily rations. It feels tacky, and only late in the game does Riggen find the script’s most interesting idea, about unwanted celebrity. Miner story, major fail.
Follow Joshua Rothkopf on Twitter: @joshrothkopf
Cast and crew
Cote de Pablo