Time Out says
While visually stunning and stocked with enviable onscreen talent, this holiday confection falls flat.
There’s a reason why The Nutcracker is almost always performed as a ballet. More Terry Gilliam than Walt Disney, E.T.A. Hoffmann’s original fairy tale is a dark story about a young girl, a dashing nutcracker soldier, some transformative magic and a greedy Mouse King. So, in choosing this for their next Christmas extravaganza, the Mouse House has set itself quite a challenge—and it’s one that just doesn’t come off.
All the elements are there: The production design and special effects really do make everything magical, Mackenzie Foy is the right mix of thoughtful and plucky as the heroine, and a cast boasting Keira Knightley, Helen Mirren, Morgan Freeman and Richard E. Grant is hardly short of chops. But the story is a tangled mess.
A young girl, Clara (Foy), mourning her dead mother, must unlock a mechanical egg to find the last Christmas gift she left behind. Before she can do so, she must attend a ball hosted by her godfather (Freeman), who may have the key she needs. But to find it, she must venture down a dark passageway, through a fallen hollow tree and into a snowy landscape.
So far, so Narnia. But then it all goes a bit haywire, with characters introduced only to disappear and plot points left unexplained. Some of the dialogue is astonishingly clunky, too. Knightley, especially, has to deliver some real howlers as the Sugar Plum Fairy. Try as they might, the other actors seem to lose heart amid a blizzard of shoddy lines.
On the upside, Jack Whitehall has a nice comedic turn as a quill-pushing soldier trying to fill out a mouse-related questionnaire and the beautiful ballet sequences will make this one for dance lovers to revisit. But perversely, a family film this is not: The Mouse King—actually a writhing body of mice all working together as one moving mass—is the stuff of children’s nightmares, as are a bunch of grotesque spinning clowns, one of the original elements restored to Hoffmann’s dark tale. Our advice? Leave this nutcracker on the shelf where it belongs.
Cast and crew
Richard E Grant