florida-garden
Florida Garden
Florida Garden

The Best Toasted Sandwiches in Buenos Aires

A basic guide to one of Buenos Aires’ most iconic gastronomic staples.

Advertising

First things first — what exactly is a tostado? Alongside café con leche and the medialuna, it’s a key part of Buenos Aires’ food identity. A classic of everyday life, it can appear at breakfast, a quick lunch, or afternoon snack. At its core, it’s a grilled white-bread sandwich simply filled with cooked ham and melted cheese.

Its story dates back to Italian immigration, which brought the tramezzino to Argentina. At first, the tostado was a luxury item — served only in distinguished cafés and functioning as a symbol of urban sophistication. The local twist was to toast that delicate triangular sandwich, often brushed with a thin layer of butter to achieve the golden sheen that became its hallmark.

Over time, the tostado became democratized, no longer confined to historic cafés. Today it’s enjoying a new chapter, appearing in specialty coffee shops and modern bars that play with the original recipe. You’ll find it made with pita, brioche, or sourdough bread; filled with tomatoes, cheese blends, vegetarian variations without ham, or even chef-style sauces. Of course, mixto purists will say that with such tweaks, it shouldn’t even be called tostado.

Whether paired with a double espresso, a glass bottle of Coke, or a cold beer, the tostado remains a porteño ritual. In this guide, we spotlight the classics that never disappoint — and a few modern twists worth trying.

1. Florida Garden

A true survivor on Florida Street, Florida Garden is a classic among classics. Witness to Buenos Aires’ golden and hard times alike, it made its mark long before the specialty coffee trend arrived — here, they were talking about gourmet coffee before it was cool.

And on its menu, the tostado has always been an emblem. Made with a double portion of cheese, natural ham (not pressed), and a touch of butter that keeps it fresh and flavorful, it perfectly represents the city’s afternoon snack tradition.

Tip: Try their “Café a la italiana” — espresso, Strega liqueur, cream, and cinnamon. It’s a trip back to old Buenos Aires.

Where: Florida 899.

2. Café Paulín

Self-proclaimed as “the most famous in Buenos Aires,” Café Paulín’s sandwiches more than earn their fame. Their legendary “flying sandwiches” add a touch of showmanship that made them iconic — and viral in the social media era.

But it’s their high-quality ingredients and simple combinations that explain their staying power. Paulín is also one of the few porteño bars boasting an entire section dedicated to tostados: the “Académico” adds fresh tomato, while the “Americano” dares to use pita bread.

Tip: It deserves a list of its own, but the figazza (flatbread) with flank steak and cheese is another must-try.

Where: Sarmiento 635.

Advertising

3. Los Galgos

The tostado at Los Galgos borders on perfection. It arrives beautifully plated: evenly toasted bread, cut into neat triangles forming a symmetrical square. It’s a classic with no gimmicks, yet every detail speaks of quality. The ham is natural and well chosen; the cheese, smooth and creamy, melts just right — achieving that balance that elevates a simple tostado into a true Buenos Aires icon.

Tip: They serve tostados until 8 p.m.; after that, the dinner menu takes over.

Where: Av. Callao 501.

4. El Timón de Don Jesús

On the border between Palermo and Colegiales, there’s a corner that resists passing trends. El Timón de Don Jesús is a classic bodegón — an old-school neighborhood eatery that’s become an institution.

Also of interest: The best miga sandwiches in Buenos Aires

Among its hearty dishes, the tostado stands out as a lunch favorite: it comes in a giant, fully loaded portion, with the kind of generosity only a true barrio bar can offer.

Tip: Order half a portion — it’s almost impossible for one person to finish the whole thing.

Where: Av. Dorrego 1695.

Advertising

5. Confitería Zurich

Traditional cafés are the new black of Buenos Aires snacks — retro is back, and in full swing. This bar-bistro facing Plaza Manuel Belgrano stands out with its own personality: dark wooden furniture, metal milk jugs, bow-tied waiters, and napkins declaring “always new, always classic.”

With that spirit, it can hold its own against any specialty coffee spot nearby. The tostados are emblematic: generous triangles, perfectly melted cheese, and golden bread toasted to perfection. Pure nostalgia, served on a tray.

Tip: At “La Zurich,” you can also travel back in time with their 1980s classics like filet mignon with mushrooms, chicken in green onion sauce, or mini steak sandwiches.

Where: Cuba 1999.

6. Barragán Café

Paying homage to El Chavo del 8, Barragán — a “porteño-mex” café — offers a tostado called “Torta de Jamón” that’s a true delight. Instead of white sandwich bread, it uses brioche; instead of butter, a cilantro lactonesa (light mayo). The result is divine: soft inside, crispy outside. Perfect for a sunny mid-morning snack enjoyed outdoors.

Tip: Ask for the little bottled sauces — the “Piña de Habanero” adds a sweet and spicy touch you’ll thank us for later.

Where: Nicasio Oroño 1195.

Advertising

7. Shokupan

Shokupan is Buenos Aires’ haven for Japanese milk bread: soft, slightly sweet, and so fluffy it melts in your mouth. Recently, they started serving it toasted — earning them a spot on this list. Shokupan doesn’t do the traditional mixto; instead, it offers minimalist fillings and artisanal presentation, like tempeh with kimchi.

Tip: You can buy their loaf bread to take home — a soft, spongy slice of happiness.

Where: Loyola 1620.

8. Sicilia Deco e Caffé

Here’s a tip you probably didn’t know: a new gem just opened in Colegiales. Sicilia Deco e Caffé is a beautiful space that evokes the belle époque of Buenos Aires, set inside a restored casa chorizo that honors the city’s Italian heritage.

Also of interest: 10 specialty coffee shops that are kids friendly in Buenos Aires

Every detail is designed to create a warm, comforting experience — from the décor to the menu. And alongside the specialty coffee, you’ll find a memorable tostado with brie, mozzarella, and tomato, finished with a touch of mustard.

Tip: Not technically a tostado, but equally delicious — the pumpkin and brie sandwich makes for a perfect veggie lunch option.

Where: Dorrego 1588.

Recommended
    You may also like
    You may also like
    Advertising