Get us in your inbox

Honeypie Cafe
Photograph: Michael GoelzerHoneypie Cafe

The 12 best pies in America for your holiday feast

What’s that? The holidays are here? It’s time to treat yourself to the best pies in America

Written by
Shoshi Parks
Contributors
Patty Lee
&
Sarah Medina
Advertising

Celebrate the season of overindulgence by picking up one of the best pies in America and plopping it at the center of your holiday table. You don't have to be in New York or L.A. (or Ronks, Pennsylvania, for that matter) to get your hands on the country’s favorite pies, either—most of these baked beauties can be shipped cross-country, just in time for friends and family to gather 'round.

And there’s more to holiday pie than just pumpkin and pecans. Go old-school with a Southern sweet potato pie from Atlanta, or an early Americana-style shoo-fly pie from Pennsylvania. Dig into regional specialties like Portland's blueberry pie (made from wild fruit harvested in Maine) or try chocolate haupia (coconut) pie from the island of Oahu. Looking for something out of the box? Order up an unexpected creation like Momofuku's famed milk bar pie in NYC, or Spinning J Bakery’s key lime-hibiscus pie in Chicago.

RECOMMENDED: the one thing you have to eat in every state in America

Whether you stick to tradition or start a brand new one, we'll help you follow the sweet scent (virtually, or in-person) to some of the best bakeries in the USA. While you're at it, consider ordering up some sweets from the best chocolate shops in the country, too. We promise neither you or your guests will be able to resist these best pies in America.

Best pies in America, ranked

With its “go big or go home” mentality, it’s no surprise that the Lone Star State is the birthplace of this deep-dish behemoth. Towering over most other pastries, the aptly named Lord of the Pies calls for a whopping 10 whole Granny Smith apples—the fruit’s tart punch is tempered by Emporium Pie’s rich house-made caramel and a generous heap of cinnamon crumb topping. A tender, all-butter crust completes the Texan showstopper.

Discover Dallas:  
🍴 The best restaurants in Dallas
📍 The best things to do in Dallas

When it comes to iconic foods, Maine has two: lobster and blueberries. And just like a good lobster roll, a superb blueberry pie relies on the freshness and simplicity of its key ingredient. In the case of Two Fat Cats, a quaint bakery in Maine, this means forgoing bigger cultivated berries for the tinier, wild varieties—the select fruit gives the oozing innards of this rustic double-crust pie a more intense blueberry flavor.

Discover Maine:   
📍 The best things to do in Portland
📍 The best things to do in Maine

Advertising

The pint-size Lower East Side pie shop opened a charming Clinton Hill café that has become one of our favorite date spots in NYC. Petee’s bakes many sweets we love, like icebox lemon poppy-seed meringue and banana cream pies, but the absolute best for the Thanksgiving season is the creamy coconut custard. And if you're looking for a baking project, Petra Paredez recently released her first cookbook, Pie for Everyone.

Discover New York: 
🍴 The best restaurants in NYC
🥧 The best pies in NYC

Since "Momma" Lucy Jackson opened Atlanta's Busy Bee Cafe in 1947, it has proudly prepared some of the best Southern soul food around. But their old-fashioned sweet potato pie is a downright masterpiece. Slightly sweet and delicately spiced with nutmeg and cinnamon, its creamy and moist filling is a simple take on a classic Southern specialty.

Discover Atlanta:  
🍴 The best restaurants in Atlanta
📍 The best things to do in Atlanta

Advertising

Years before Grant Achatz became a food-world luminary, second cousins Dave and Wendy were building a pastry empire in the family’s native Michigan. The self-taught bakers shot to pie-slinging fame with this streusel-topped beauty, available at Achatz Handmade Pie Co. Sweetened with just a touch of sugar, the delightfully tart filling allows the plump, locally-grown blueberries, blackberries, raspberries, and cherries to shine.

Discover Ann Arbor: 
🍴 The best restaurants in Ann Arbor
📍 The best things to do in Ann Arbor

Travel back in time (if only for an hour) at this charming Humboldt Park pie and soda shop that's outfitted with old-timey barstools and beautiful vintage accents. Despite its decor, the pies on offer aren't stuck in the past: Diners can choose from imaginative flavors like yuzu-matcha meringue, s'mores, lemon-lavender, and key lime-hibiscus. Order a slice and a house-made soda, hunker down in a booth and transport yourself to simpler times.

Discover Chicago: 
🍴 The best restaurants in Chicago
🥧 The 
best pies in Chicago

Advertising

Every so often, a dish becomes such a hit, it’s practically synonymous with an eatery. Such is the case with this pie from Liz Prueitt and Chad Robertson’s award-winning Tartine Bakery. A smear of bittersweet chocolate acts as a barrier between filling and shell, ensuring a flaky crust with every bite and balancing out the sweetness of the banana-studded pastry cream. Chocolate shavings finish the delightfully messy confection. Plus, you can get it from Tartine's L.A. locations, too.

Discover San Francisco: 
🍴 The best restaurants in San Francisco
🥧 The best pies in San Francisco

Dutch Haven's take on the Pennsylvania Dutch specialty, shoo-fly pie, was once named America's best. The ooey-gooey confection is made with simple, always-available-even-in-the-dead-of-Pennsylvania-winter ingredients like molasses, sugar, and shortening. When cooked, its filling and wet bottom crust are reminiscent of a richly sweet, slightly creamy pecan pie—minus the nuts.

Advertising

Nicole Rucker's pies come brimming with bright pops of acidity and sweetness from the season’s freshest produce—carefully sourced and inspected by Rucker herself—and silken with butter or custard or chocolate. At her stand inside Grand Central Market in L.A. you can find some of her most iconic baked goods (light-as-air key lime pie, anyone?), as well as newer creations such as cookie-crust pies and savory hand pies. 

Discover Los Angeles: 
🍴 The best restaurants in L.A.
🥧 The best pies in L.A.

Oahu’s top pie purveyor sits on the island’s North Shore, home to some of the Aloha State’s most epic waves. This laidback gem’s custard two-fer is just as legendary as the surf, and it’s been a menu staple since Ted’s opened in 1987. A velvety layer of haupia (coconut) pudding infuses a touch of tropical flair into the unconventional chocolate-cream pie.

Discover Oahu: 
🍴 The best restaurants in Oahu
📍 The best things to do in Oahu

Advertising

Cozy diner Honeypie Cafe proudly reps its Midwestern roots with gussied-up comfort food and desserts. To form her luscious homage to old-fashioned black-bottomed pies, baking guru Valeri Lucks marries two of her bestsellers, layering chocolate and banana custards—both made with Wisconsin milk—atop a crisp graham cracker crust. She crowns the glorious affair with a mound of fresh whipped cream, which every pie-lover knows is an essential addition.

Discover Milwaukee: 
🍴 The best restaurants in Milwaukee 

📍 The best things to do in Milwaukee

Christina Tosi’s legendary salty-sweet creation from Momofuku Milk Bar was a happy accident, according to legend. A giant crumbled oat cookie subs in for your standard-issue crust, which is draped in a gooey butter filling shot with vanilla and—surprise ingredient—corn powder. The best part? Now, you can get a fresh pie delivery anywhere in the USA.

Recommended
    You may also like
      Advertising