1 Love It
Save it

'La donna del lago': our verdict

Did the lady of the lake float our boat? Find out in our review of the Royal Opera House's production of Rossini's opera

© Bill Cooper
There is usually a reason why an opera is ‘rarely performed’, such as it being a complete turkey. Rossini’s ‘La donna del lago’ is such a work. It sets Sir Walter Scott’s poem ‘The Lady of the Lake’ – a preposterously romanticised view of Highland life – in the sixteenth-century, and begins the action with a king wandering incognito around an enemy camp in search of the titular Elena, whom he loves. She, however, has been expediently betrothed to a Highland warrior from another clan – the un-Scottishly named ‘Rodrigo’. Her heart, though, belongs to another ferocious kilt-wearer called Malcom.

Director John Fulljames stages the work in an ironic fashion. The characters are literally museum pieces removed from their cases before, from the edges of the stage, Scott and his frock-coated, Edinburgh Enlightenment chums sip brandy and gamely watch the tartan-tastic vision unfold – the two worlds neatly juxtaposing as the gentlemen enjoy a primly carved lamb supper, while centre-stage two clansmen are stripped to the waist eviscerating a ram for their meal.
At one point a Scott figure (tenor Robin Leggate) even intervenes to place a ring on the finger of one of the characters, as if he is in the process of literary invention. This is the problem with Fulljames’s conception – while it points up the absurdly romantic take on tribal Scotland, it also distances the audience from the main story by presenting it as fiction. It all takes place on designer Dick Bird’s giant revolving staircase, an object that curiously does not seem to belong in either of the onstage worlds.

What saves the day is the extraordinary singing. American mezzo Joyce di Donato is superb as Elena, her warm characterisation and powerful, creamy voice filling the auditorium; nimble Peruvian tenor Juan Diego Flórez matches her technically by floating out high-register coloratura (his Act II ‘O fiamma soave’ bringing proceedings to a standstill). As his kilt-wearing rival Rodrigo, Michael Spyres (standing in for an indisposed Colin Lee) gives his dramatic tenor a terrific workout through the punishing tessitura of his role. The true holder of Elena’s heart, Malcom, is sung passionately by mezzo Daniela Barcellona in a trouser/kilt role. Simón Orfila is a suitably gruff bass as Duglas, clan chieftain and Elena’s father.

In the pit, conductor Michele Mariotti produces a splendid performance from his orchestra, making the most of the score and enlivening a laborious, clumsily structured tale with occasional flashes of Rossini’s genius.

Read more classical and opera features

James Rhodes

In his own words, five things you didn't know about the maverick pianist

Read more

Fflur Wyn

The Welsh soprano tells us about playing unusual roles, including a polar bear

Read more

Andrew Smith

The British-Norwegian composer talks to us about his requiem, a response to the 2011 atrocity on Utøya

Read more

Steve Reich

The influential composer tells us about the American style making classical music popular again

Read more

Julian Anderson

What exactly does composing entail? The award-winning composer reveals all

Read more

Sakari Oramo

As the conductor picks up the BBC baton, we ask Oramo to define his electrifying approach to orchestral performance

Read more

Angel Blue

Talented soprano Angel Blue explains why quitting was never an option

Read more

François-Xavier Roth

Roth is set to conduct Stravinsky's 'The Rite of Spring' at the BBC Proms. He tells us why his recreation of the 1913 premiere will shock us all

Read more
Show more
Read more classical and opera features