Sorry, transplants: Miami is officially more expensive than NYC, says distressing new data

If you moved from NYC to South Florida over the last few years expecting cheap rent, palm-lined financial freedom and a break from NYC prices, your sunny dreams are about to be shattered. According to the latest Regional Price Parities report from the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the Miami metro area has officially dethroned New York City as the second most expensive place to live in the entire nation, sitting just behind the San Francisco Bay Area.

The agency gave Miami a staggering score of 114.155 compared to NYC’s 112.563. What does that mean? Well, since 100 is the national average, South Florida is no longer just a playground for the rich—it’s a city where only the rich can afford to stay.

RECOMMENDED: Miami was just ranked the most “high risk” housing market in the world—here’s what that means for locals

How did Miami get so pricey? It turns out that the increase of nearly 900,000 new residents in the Sunshine State—including over 50,000 fleeing New York—had a major effect on local prices.

Since 2019, consumer prices in Miami have skyrocketed by 36-percent, with home prices leaping a jaw-dropping 79-percent since the pandemic. Factor in average home insurance premiums hovering around $8,292, climbing private-school tuitions and dining costs that now outpace Midtown Manhattan, Florida’s famous "no-income-tax" advantage is shrinking fast.

While billionaires like Jeff Bezos, Elon Musk and Larry Page are happily snapping up South Florida real estate, local residents are feeling the squeeze. A typical Miami homebuyer now needs an income between $160,000 and $215,000 to break into the market. Meanwhile, local salaries haven't quite gotten up to speed—a family in the Miami metro area still earns about $12,000 less than the national average, and an average New York City lawyer still takes home about $51,000 more than one in the 305.

So if you’re planning a move down south to save some money, you might want to recalculate your budget. You’ll definitely get plenty of year-round sunshine, but that bronzed glow is going to cost you a whole lot more than you thought.