The 9 best restaurants in Reykjavik

Dreamy seafood is served with a side of jaw-dropping views in the Icelandic capital
By Rosie Gizauskas |
Advertising

Reykjavik is hot right now. (Okay, it’s freezing, but you get the gist.) And it’s also a foodie heaven, especially if you’re into fish and meat. Try the likes of whale, horse and puffin if you’re brave  and if you’re not there’s also a burgeoning vegan scene. The city’s reputation for Nordic cool is well-earned, and you’ll see chic-looking types dressed in black drinking beers on every street here, or down at the Reykjavik Street Food Market which is open every Saturday on Fógetagarður Square. Food doesn’t come cheap in the notoriously pricey city, especially when you’re chowing down on fresh seafood and food direct from the farm, but you always can expect perfectly fresh produce in this down-to-earth yet super-trendy city.

Best restaurants in Reykjavik

1
Grillmarkaðurinn
Photograph: Courtesy Grillmarkaðurinn

Grillmarkaðurinn

Why go? You’ll feel like you’re eating a steak in the garden of Eden.

Grillmarkaðurinn means grill market in English, and that’s exactly what you’ll get here. This restaurant is decorated with moss and trees and sources local farm produce before grilling and smoking it to perfection. Vegans look away now: you can order whale, horse, reindeer and puffin here, although you can also play it safe and stick with a classic beef steak. And make sure you have a delicious gin cocktail, too. The Kardashians ate here on a trip to Reykjavik, and if it’s good enough for them…

Price range: High-end

2
Kopar
Photograph: Courtesy Kopar

Kopar

Why go? You’ll be seeing stars after trying the fish here.

It wouldn’t be a legitimate trip to Iceland without at least trying to see the Northern Lights. Load up on a nine (yes, really) course dinner at Kopar in Reykjavik’s Old Harbour. Best are the fish-based dishes like cod tongue, scallops with ceviche and monkfish with pesto and bacon. You’ll then head out on a boat to try and spot the elusive Aurora Borealis with a skipper - and will hopefully return after two and half hours victorious.

Price range: High-end

Advertising
3
Mathús Garðabæjar
Photograph: Courtesy SIGURJON RAGNAR

Mathús Garðabæjar

Why go? It’s cosy, homely and totally un-touristy  with the best brunch in town.

You’ll have to go off the beaten just track a little for this local gem, which is in Garðabær, a countryside area just outside the city. And that means it’s that rarity in Reykjavik  affordable. Check the duck leg and the lobster bisque, as well as the chicken sesame noodles, pancakes and mimosas for brunch.

Price range: Mid-range

4
Gló
Photograph: Courtesy Gló

Gló

Why go? For healthy, organic food with decent vegan options in an airy upstairs restaurant.

You might have noticed that there’s a lot of whale and reindeer on the menu in this city - if that’s not your bag, Gló is for you. It’s not exclusively vegan and veggie, but is all organic, fresh stuff, in a cafeteria-style setup. (Except we doubt you ate this healthily at school!) Try the rainbow Asian salads, falafel and flatbreads, as well as the Mexican wrap and mix-and-match salads. There are four branches across the city.

Price range: Budget

Advertising
5
Bergsson RE
Photograph: Courtesy Bergsson RE

Bergsson RE

Why go? For the freshest of fish  and the waterside view.

The views over the harbour from this wharf restaurant are so magnificent that you could be paying a million Icelandic Krona to dine here  but in reality, this place comes in a little more on budget. Try the cod with Béarnaise sauce as well as the homemade bread and ask the waiter to help you with the menu  written on a chalkboard in Icelandic. Like roulette, with delicious fish.

Price: Mid-range

6
Coocoo's Nest
Photograph: Courtesy Coocoo's Nest

The Coocoo's Nest

Why go? For the tacos on a Tuesday. 

Vegan and family-run, this is another food spot with great vegan options. The restaurant is located in an old fishing shed, but it’s not as fishy as it sounds. It’s lovely and light inside. You’ll find all sorts on the menu, from sourdough pizzas to big leafy salads, and then there’s Taco Tuesdays. You might be in Iceland, but you can’t miss out on the mouthwatering fish ones here  and prices are reasonable, too.

Price: Mid-range

Advertising
7
Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur
Photograph: Courtesy Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur

Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur

Why go? It’s a cult classic, world-famous hot dog stand that’s been running since 1937 (Bill Clinton has eaten there).

Situated in central Reykjavik near to the harbour, this is the perfect hidden gem if you want a delicious dinner without a hefty price tag. Ask for a loaded lamb or beef hot dog with ‘the works’, which includes fried onion, raw onion, ketchup, and remolaði, a mayonnaise and mustard relish. Make sure to get a beer on the side. There’s nowhere to sit here, but you won’t care when you taste how good these bad boys are.  

Price range: Budget

8
Dill, Reykjavik
Photograph: Courtesy Lilja Jons

Dill

Why go? For a blowout meal with incredible views of Iceland’s jaw-dropping natural wonders.

New Nordic cuisine isn’t done any better than at Dill a Michelin-starred restaurant, serving up seasonal ingredients and classics like meatballs, fish stew and goat’s cheese, as well as truly Icelandic dishes like reindeer tartar. It’s known as the best restaurant in Reykjavik for a reason.

Price: Blow out

Advertising
9
Hverfisgata 12
Photograph: Courtesy Hverfisgata 12

Hverfisgata 12

Why go? For the best pizza you’ll get in Reykjavik.

This small, family-run restaurant is a secret among locals. (It has no sign outside!) It serves up some of the most delicious Italian food you’ll find in the city as the chef comes from Naples. Go for a pizza and try toppings like roasted kale and lamb or spicy sausage with pickled chilli. There’s also a decent range of craft beers on tap.

Price: Mid-range

Advertising
This page was migrated to our new look automatically. Let us know if anything looks off at feedback@timeout.com