This 10-year-old shop feels more like an old-school deli than an ice cream parlor, where cured meats hang from the ceiling and walls are lined with wine. Despite the market feel, the gelato—and the sandwiches, for that matter—are legit. There are 24 flavors available, ranging from lemon cookie and white chocolate raspberry to caramel balsamic and banana heath bar. Best of all, the shop is open until midnight seven days a week, to the delight of the post-happy hour crowds.