Get us in your inbox


Antica Pizzeria (CLOSED)

  • Restaurants
  • Edgewater
  • price 2 of 4
  • 4 out of 5 stars

Time Out says

4 out of 5 stars

First, a quick note about vocabulary: When I tell you that Antica Pizzeria is a “simple” restaurant, I mean this in the most school-yard, Merriam-Webster kind of way. This is not the word tossed around by many other Italian restaurants, places that put out “simple” creations, like exotic mushrooms tossed in artisanal olive oil and sprinkled with rare sea salt. At Antica, the dining room is so nondescript I hardly remember being in it, and the only thing that’s rare is the naked honesty of the food. When there are mushrooms, they are big, chunky things, so fresh that they don’t need anything but the bruschetta beneath them. And the pizza, the restaurant’s centerpiece, is a bit of a revelation. The Margherita may not pass muster with Neapolitan snobs—the crust is just millimeters too thick and a little too dry. But anybody who can get past those details will be rewarded with a very fine pie, one with a crisp crust and a piquant sauce layered with sweetness and spice and cut by the tang of mozzarella. The nuances of the sauce can get lost amid the ham, eggs, peas and mushrooms (as on the fattoressa pizza). But it is a praiseworthy pie nonetheless—not because it’s complicated, but specifically because it isn’t.

Written by David Tamarkin


5663 N Clark St
Cross street:
between Olive and Hollywood Aves
El stop:Red to Bryn Mawr. Bus:22,50.
Average main course: $18; average pizza: $14.50
Opening hours:
Dinner (closed Tue)
Do you own this business?
Sign in & claim business
You may also like