Curiosity will tempt and, ultimately, defeat you at this sandwich-and-slice shop. Because, really, what red-blooded American can resist ordering a slice of pizza that promises to be not just "big" but "bigger"? Well, America, prepare for regret: this massive slice of bland New York–style pizza is remarkable only for its size. Ditto for the bigger "Carlos" sandwich, a tepid take on the Cubano. A fresh Greek salad is well-prepared if predictable. Even so, Big Stuff proves that bigger isn't better—it's just…bigger.