Peter Pan’s Shadow Part One: Neverland at Dream Theatre Company | Theater review

Jeremy Menekseoglu trains his grim vision on the boy who wouldn’t grow up.
Photograph: courtesy of Dream Theatre Company Mishelle Apalategui and Annelise Lawson in�Peter Pan's Shadow Part One: Neverland at Dream Theatre Company

The first installment of Jeremy Menekseoglu’s new three-part take on J.M. Barrie’s classic children’s story brings to the forefront a fact—known to teachers and parents—that’s usually skirted in more kid-friendly adaptations: Children, for all their wide-eyed innocence, can make for despicable human beings. Petulant, morbidly curious, emotionally volatile and narcissistic, Menekseoglu’s knife-wielding Peter Pan (Mishelle Apalategui) bears almost as much resemblance to one of Anthony Burgess’s droogs as Barrie’s boy who never ages.

Looking for a quick dose of validation, Peter drags Tinker Bell (Annelise Lawson, playing Tina Turner to Peter’s Ike) to his mourning mother’s window, hoping for a glimpse of some emotionally satisfying grief. Instead, he meets his kid sister (Anna W. Menekseoglu), and after a brief excursion to a production of Pirates of Penzance in pursuit of Mom and Dad, decides he too should become a pirate king. Back in Neverland, that post, of course, is already occupied.

Jeremy Menekseoglu, who also directs, achieves some whimsy here and there—Captain Hook’s deadpan amputation earns a genuine laugh, and the projections by Lawson add an element of fantasy—but he doesn’t deliver on his promising concept of a darker exploration of Peter’s world. Part One is too grim for young audiences but too thematically slight for adults. Part Two opens in May; that leaves three months for Peter Pan’s Shadow to grow out of its own arrested development.

This page was migrated to our new look automatically. Let us know if anything looks off at