The best Chicago theater of 2017

Kokandy Productions

Director Lili-Anne Brown’s long-simmering staging of the funkified 1970s Wizard of Oz update pulsated with affection for the material. With a cast led by Sydney Charles’s Dorothy (deliciously supported by the likes of Nicole Michelle Haskins, Gilbert Domally, Chuckie Benson and Steven Perkins) and giddily inventive designs by Arnel Sancianco and Virginia Varland, the spring production truly brought no bad news.

Griffin Theatre Company

The musical adaptation of E.L. Doctorow’s novel, about social turmoil at the turn of the 20th century as experienced by three intersecting ethnic groups—WASPy whites, aspirational African-Americans and Eastern European immigrants—has become a staple in the two decades since its debut (so much so that another local production will bow in January at the Marriott). Rising director Scott Weinstein’s immersive staging eschewed the bombast baked into the original, paring the score down to two pianos and letting the actors roam among the audience—for a product so efficiently affecting even Henry Ford would’ve loved it.

About Face Theatre and Theater Wit

The Chicago premiere of this anti-romantic comedy by Joshua Harmon (Bad Jews) saw Alex Weisman cast as Jordan, the perpetually single, borderline obsessive gay man watching the clock tick toward his 30s as his best girlfriends keep getting married. Harmon’s razor-sharp script captured a disarmingly up-to-the-moment set of social anxieties—now that we have marriage equality, is it even worse to be unmarried? And Keira Fromm’s savvy production gave us a last precision turn by Weisman, who’s been winning over Chicago audiences since his professional debut in The History Boys at TimeLine nearly a decade ago, before he left town for his upcoming Broadway bow in a little show called Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.

Victory Gardens Theater

The 2015 Tony Award winner for Best Musical, sensitively adapted by Jeanine Tesori and Lisa Kron from lesbian cartoonist Alison Bechdel’s memoir of discovering her sexuality at the same time she learned her dad was secretly gay, has always been an intimate affair. And while Victory Gardens’s production, directed by Gary Griffin, was even sparer than the in-the-round Broadway staging, it was no less compelling, with rich musical direction by Doug Peck, moving turns by stalwart actors Danni Smith (pictured) and Rob Lindley, and a breakout performance by Hannah Starr as college-aged, coming-out Medium Alison.

Haven Theatre

NYC experimentalist playwright Young Jean Lee had a higher-profile Chicago production this year with Straight White Men at Steppenwolf (which will go higher profile still when Steppenwolf’s Anna D. Shapiro directs a Broadway transfer next summer starring Armie Hammer and Tom Skerritt). Much as I loved that subversive script, though, I got a more visceral jolt from this small-scale Lee piece, a punk-rock monologue with songs about confronting mortality, led in director Josh Sobel’s bracing production by galvanic tricksy dream girl Isa Arciniegas.

Broken Nose Theatre

Few, including me, saw this storefront sleeper hit coming. On paper, writer Michael Perlman’s play sounded like a millennial retread of the well-worn Big Chill model. And that’s what it was, but also so much more; Perlman’s script dealt honestly with interpersonal realities of social media and “social justice,” identity politics and identity crises. Elevated by a deeply invested ensemble cast under Spenser Davis’s sharp direction, At the Table became one of the year’s most sought-after seats among those in the know.

Definition Theatre Company

Branden Jacobs-Jenkins’s fiery satirical deconstruction of The Octoroon, a real-life race melodrama by 19th-century Irish actor-playwright Dion Boucicault, took its time to find a Chicago production after playing New York, D.C., London and other cities. But the young Definition Theatre Company proved a proper match for this daring, discombobulating metatheatrical thrill ride, with a top-notch cast that confidently navigated all of Jacobs-Jenkins’s breakneck curves.

Teatro Vista

Writer-performer Sandra Delgado filled in a blank in Chicago’s history with this conjuring of a long-forgotten Lakeview nightclub that was a gathering place for Latinx immigrants in the 1950s and ’60s. In a setting that evoked the nightclub itself, we met fictionalized patrons of La Havana Madrid (composites of real-life regulars) and heard their stories, accompanied by Latin band Carpacho y Su Super Combo and watched over by Delgado herself, whose club-singer character was a kind of summoning spirit of Chicago’s Latino legacy.

Goodman Theatre

I don’t always love to see our local theater institutions importing actors from New York or elsewhere rather than drawing from Chicago’s own rich talent pool. But it was hard to fault the Goodman for bringing the 2015 debut production of this searing piece by Branden Jacobs-Jenkins (yep, him again) in wholesale from NYC, cast, creative team and director Evan Cabnet intact. The indelible play drew you in as a smart satire of young professionals before pulling a chilling bait-and-switch; this ensemble (led by the incisive Ryan Spahn) steered into the darkness with aplomb.

Steppenwolf Theatre Company

You can’t always immediately tell on your way out of the theater which plays are going to stick with you most persistently. The staying power that Antoinette Nwandu’s Steppenwolf world premiere had in my head was certainly enhanced by the heated conversation it sparked across the city last summer. But Nwandu’s skillful, piercing recasting of Waiting for Godot as an allegory of young black men in America waiting for a change has held on in my thoughts on its own merits: the strikingness of its visuals, the economy of its language, the generous intensity of its performances. With the surprise news earlier this month, reported by the Chicago Tribune, that Spike Lee quietly filmed Danya Taymor’s production over the summer—and that the resulting film featuring original cast members Jon Michael Hill, Julian Parker and Ryan Hallahan will be screened at Sundance in January—it seems Pass Over is about to be on a lot more minds.