Top Dog Diner

Restaurants Soho
3 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars
(60user reviews)
Top Dog (© Jamie Lau)
1/5
© Jamie Lau
Top Dog (© Jamie Lau)
2/5
© Jamie Lau
Top Dog (© Jamie Lau)
3/5
© Jamie Lau
Top Dog (© Jamie Lau)
4/5
© Jamie Lau
Top Dog (© Jamie Lau)
5/5
© Jamie Lau

Please note, Top Dog Diner is now closed. Time Out eating & drinking editors July 2016.

The hot dogs at this new Soho eatery are about as pretty as hot dogs get. Artful lattices of sauce from a squeezy bottle announce that Top Dog wants to give the humble tube steak the Best in Show award in the Crufts of gastronomy. The proprietors put a ‘healthy’ spin on their offering, and the pups are produced in London. 

As someone who grew up eating (and loving) hot dogs in New York, I applaud every effort to get serious about these tubes of delight. And I enjoyed eating a couple of times at Top Dog, which has arrived in Soho to a fanfare of PR and Twitter trumpets. (Lisa Snowdon attended the launch.) It’s a nice-looking place, and blessed with friendly staff. They were still a little flustered in the first week, as some systems were not fully up to speed, but a second visit a week later went much more smoothly.

On our first visit, our duo of dogs disappointed us. We ordered the ‘Soho’ (£4.95) and the ‘Sloppy’ (£7.50). When they arrived, we couldn’t tell which was which and neither, initially, could the waiting staff. After conferring, they pointed out a small fringe of baked beans peeping out of the cleft in the Sloppy. That minimal difference carried on in the eating experience. The two dogs didn’t taste very different from one other. They were perfectly OK, but they were undistinguished.

Second time round we barked enthusiastically for the Chicago and Kimchi version, which were more clearly distinguishable one from the other. The latter didn’t taste like kimchi, the Korean pickled-cabbage condiment that gives it its name, but it was good. Both cost £7.50.

We had two sides, fries and apple slaw. The fries were of unusually good quality, thin-cut and addictively crunchy. The slaw (£2) was more like sauerkraut than coleslaw on our first visit, dominated by the flavours of fermentation. On the second visit it was better, but we thought the recipe could benefit from a rethink.

Hot dog + side dish should = lunch. After finishing here, we still felt hungry. Which wouldn’t be so bad, but this light meal can set you back a schnauzer’s-hair over 20 quid (before tip). Spending the same amount at Herman ze German (there’s a branch one minute’s walk away) could render you immobile.

We liked the idea of Top Dog, and we liked being there. With luck, they’ll do what it takes to make them truly the top dog. They’ve got the bark. What they need is the bite.

By: Richard Ehrlich

Posted:

Venue name: Top Dog Diner
Contact:
Address: 48 Frith Street
London
W1D 4SF
Transport: Tube: Tottenham Court Rd or Leicester Square.
Price: Meal for two with drinks and service: around £20
Do you own this business?
Static map showing venue location

Average User Rating

4.6 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:49
  • 4 star:4
  • 3 star:4
  • 2 star:2
  • 1 star:1
LiveReviews|60
2 people listening
1 of 1 found helpful
Staff Writer

Great hot dogs, done with all the gluttony and decadence that you'd expect from the Americans! The Chili Dog is amazing and the Salted Caramel Milkshake was insane. They are always developing new ideas like Bulleit Bourbon Floats, which is definitely on the list to try next time. Check them out

1 of 1 found helpful
Tastemaker

There was nothing bad about my meal at Top Dog, but there was also nothing that stood out for me. I like the concept, where you decide on a beef, pork or tofu hotdog and then choose from a list of toppings to customize your order. There are also classic American sides like mac n cheese and onion rings as well as a number of different types of milkshakes to choose from. The food was all okay, but not memorable. 

1 of 1 found helpful

Want to have food that takes the American dinner food and takes it to a whole new level? Here's the place to visit!

1 of 1 found helpful

Awesome hot dogs, great variety would recommend to anyone looking for a top hotdog in Soho

1 of 1 found helpful

Best hotdogs in town! And try their sweet potato chips. Genius idea!!!! Xx

1 of 1 found helpful

Great little hot dog shop. Popped in on way to many a gig. Check it out.

1 of 1 found helpful

Cool space and loving the veggie dog - a complete novelty for a vegetarian

1 of 1 found helpful

This place is AMAZING! Delicious and actually real meat!! And, it's also Kid tested while being Parent approved: milkshakes and craft beers, dogs with ketchup or Kimchi, root beer floats or Jack Daniels, skinny fries or sweet potato. Plus, it's sort of nice to have good service, even for simple good food in the heart of SoHo. Love it!

1 of 1 found helpful

I want to see Marissa Hermer run through SOHO dressed fully as a Hot Dog!

1 of 1 found helpful

Just a awesome owner! I am from America but LOVE London. Bringing a little piece of my home to my favorite place!! Just perfect!!

1 of 1 found helpful

Top Dog is a brilliant idea. Everything is sourced from the finest ingredients, but it's an old fashioned, casual nosh. Delicious, and a great atmosphere, but one you can relax in.

1 of 1 found helpful

Great food and great service the staff are extremely friendly and the manager always goes the extra mile

1 of 1 found helpful

Delicious food my kids adore, and of such high quality that my husband and I not only feel great about treating them with it, we join in! We could fill an album with photos we've taken on that motorcycle! Such fun.

1 of 1 found helpful

Top Dog brings the fun of America's favorite comfort food and upgrades it for the premium lifestyle, all with a UK flair -- haute dogs, indeed!

1 of 1 found helpful

The food is so so fresh am loving it, my journey to Soho will not be complete with a taste of TOP DOG HMMmmmmmmmm

1 of 1 found helpful

Soho is a little taste of home for me with the option of a lettuce bun!!! Cool, fun, spot a must try!!!

1 of 1 found helpful

Best hot dogs with such a wide variety you don't know which to choose first!

1 of 1 found helpful

Awesome! Better than any hot dog even in New York City. Staff was wonderful and cheerful.

1 of 1 found helpful

Best hot dog ever! And this is coming from an American!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

1 of 1 found helpful

Pulled Pork and slaw is amazing just heaven in your mouth!! The staff know there stuff

1 of 1 found helpful

Best hot dogs in London!  I'm a huge hot dog fan having been brought up on them in the U.S., so it's great to have an authentic American-style hot dog joint in Soho.  The pulled pork 'n' slaw dog is amazing, especially with a side of sweet potato fries...and a salted caramel shake!  I'm also a massive fan of their Bourbon Sour and Bulleits over Broadway bourbon cocktail with passion fruit and mint (I didn't think I liked bourbon - who knew!)  I've also hosted a party Upstairs at Top Dog and it was great fun - the staff is super friendly, yummy dogs and drinks for every liking - beer, wine and cocktails.

1 of 1 found helpful
Tastemaker

So on my way home from an event, I decided to stop off for something to eat. We all know Soho has lots to offer and I was craving a good hot dog! I've read about Top Dog so was excited to give it a try! I went for the Chilli & Cheddar beef dog which included pickled red cabbage. And it was absolutely delicious... aside from them being a little overenthusiastic with the cabbage, everything was taaassstyyy. The beef dog was meaty and firm, I'm tired of squishy fake tasting sausages so this was very welcome. The chilli on top wasn't in abundance but it was so yummy nonetheless! I had sweet potato fries as an accompaniment, which were fine, as to be expected. Only let down was the (lack of) atmosphere and price! Tad pricey at £7.50 for the dog and considering Soho was buzzing, there was no-one there. But otherwise I was a very happy customer!

1 of 1 found helpful

Ever fancy a hot dog but want somewhere with a bit more pizazz than Herman The German? Top Dog in Soho has you covered. A bit on the pricey side and not as good as Big Apple, but if you're in Soho and need a place to meet a few mates that doesn't involve waiting in queue for over an hour, there are worse places you could be. Drinks range is a plus, they've got Beavertown and Harry Brompton alcoholic Ice Tea.

1 of 1 found helpful
Staff Writer

I was on my way to another eatery when I stumbled upon Top Dog, I thought 'oh but what if I don't like it?' then figured what the hell, I'll give it a go. I am quite fussy when it comes to a hot dog- I don't have them often but when I do it has to be amazing! I was not disappointed. I went for the 'Soho' and sweet potato fries accompanied by salted caramel milkshake. Every bite was delirious, I have some chilli mayo added to my Dog and munched away in delight. I can eat a lot and love to eat- this was very appetising and very filling. I left feeling full and satisfied. A place I will recommend and do. On top of my hot dog list :) 

tastemaker

This is officially the best hot dog place in London. As someone who doesn't eat pork I often struggle to hunt down beef hot dogs, but I discovered the best ones ever in Winterville last week. It was a beef dog with chilli, and it was absolute heaven. They kindly gave me some plastic gloves with my meal as it would be messy - and I was totally thankful for this. My friend got the 'camel toe' which was a lamb dog, and there was a vegetarian leek dog option which we can't wait to back to and try. The woman that served us was so friendly and funny, we'll definitely be visiting again and again and again!!!


In America we know baseball and hot dogs..now London knows what a truly wonderful thing a gourmet hot dog can be!


Love, love, love Top Dog. Great team, great location, and the upstairs cocktail space is a total blast (I don't like Bourbon but you wouldn't even be able to tell there was Bourbon in their sour... absolutely lethal)!

Tastemaker

Meh!  In no way is the competition for Bubble dogs or Dirty bones.  Very much a take away joint which is overpriced in my opinion with no atmosphere at all.  Herman ze German does better sausages, stick with that in Soho. 


Top Dog? More like BOTTOM dog! Amirite? No, seriously, this place is the worst. The hot dogs have this horrible, icky texture. They're horrendously and uncomfortably firm and the toppings are meagre too. And christ above it's expensive. I could buy a Peugeot for half of what my meal here cost me. Ok, an old peugeot but a peugeot nonetheless. Peugeot is a funny word to spell, isn't it? Anyway, skip this place, wait til midnight and get one of those hotdogs you buy off the dudes in the street. The meat might be mysterious but we all need a little mystery in our lives. 

Show More

Snap up exclusive discounts in London

Time Out's handpicked deals — hurry, they won't be around for long...