Let's get this out of the way: Double Stuf is a mathematical lie. It feels more like a 1.5–1.75 Stuf, though that doesn't exactly pop off the packaging. Whatever the proportions, it is perfect. This achieves the ideal ratio between cookie and creme, and the classic flavor combo mandates its place at the top. But, whatever, we're eating them, not making earrings out of them.
The first reaction we had to this was a sarcastic, "I'm going to get so thin eating Oreos." And for good reason, despite these being marketed to be able to eat less of them, we're certain we'd polish off the container quickly. The wafers are crisp and the mint Stuf is perfect—just like a Girl Scout Thin Mint minus the waxy covering. We might even pop these in the freezer.
We knew these had won our hearts at first taste. First of all, they're tiny. It's adorable. Second, they taste like chocolate and peanut butter. What's not to love?
The strong peppermint flavor brought to mind Andes Chocolate Mints, Baskin-Robbins' Mint Chocolate Chip or the grasshopper cocktails served at Wisconsin supper clubs. Though one taster noted it reminded her of toothpaste, clearly in the minority. We didn't mind the strong, pleasant aftertaste one bit.
The cookie is crunchy and graham-crackery with less of that powder junk, which we're into. The stuffing looks a little weird but tastes pretty awesome. It might not taste like a s'more, but we still love them. Biggest pitfall: Why didn't Nabisco call these "S'moreos?"
Bright and citrusy, like an eggy meringue with a hint of kitchen cleaner, the Lemon rocketed up our charts. For one, it tastes like a recognizable cookie. Secondly, it brings something else to the tastebuds beyond a sugar jackhammer. For some inexplicable reason, we felt the urge to eat these with our pinkies raised while watching The Importance of Being Earnest. It's the Oreo for high tea.
One bite spurred a debate over which Girl Scout cookie this reminded us of. Is it Do-si-dos or the Tagalongs? Trick question! This totally tastes like a Nutter Butter. Filled with legitimate peanut butter, this stood out over most flavors for bringing some reality to the palate. Though it was tricky to pick up the chocolate in the cookie. (For a more balanced bite, the Reese's Mini Oreos are tight, akin to Reese's Puffs cereal.)
The least sweet of the Golden varieties, the Chocolate Creme, a.k.a. the Negative Oreo, offered a more well-done, crisp cookie reminiscent of shortbread, or yellow cake with chocolate frosting.
The hot take on the Golden cookie is that it is a better-textured cookie than the regular Oreo (and more beautiful, for what it's worth), but overly sugary when combined with the creme.