Worldwide icon-chevron-right North America icon-chevron-right United States icon-chevron-right New York State icon-chevron-right New York icon-chevron-right The best (and worst) opera and classical music of 2012
Stéphane Denève, Conducts Debussy
Joyce DiDonato, Drama Queens
Jeremy Denk, Ligeti/Beethoven
Katharina Rosenberger, Texturen
Fausto Romitelli, Anamorphosis
New York Polyphony, endBeginning
Morton Feldman, Crippled Symmetry
Michael Mizrahi, The Bright Motion
Anton Bruckner, Symphony No. 9
John Cage, The Works for Percussion 2

The best (and worst) opera and classical music of 2012

Dog Days and Debussy seized the spotlight with vital, surprising sounds

By Steve Smith

The best albums

Stéphane Denève Conducts Debussy

Stéphane Denève Conducts Debussy (Chandos)

The Royal Scottish National Orchestra celebrated Debussy's 150th birthday with a luscious, visceral survey of his major works.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

Joyce DiDonato Drama Queens

Joyce DiDonato, Drama Queens (Virgin Classics)

The much-loved mezzo showed her wild side on a CD of fiercely passionate Baroque arias.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

Jeremy Denk, Ligeti/Beethoven

Jeremy Denk, Ligeti/Beethoven (Nonesuch)

An unorthodox musical thinker, Denk engaged Beethoven’s enigmatic final sonata, dazzled in Ligeti’s études and convinced you that they belong together.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

Katharina Rosenberger, Texturen

Katharina Rosenberger, Texturen (hat[now]ART)

Rosenberger wrote these pieces between 2007 and 2011; authoritatively played by the Wet Ink Ensemble, their keen, disjunct phrases combined to speak volumes.

Layout 1

Fausto Romitelli, Anamorphosis (Tzadik)

The Talea Ensemble made an exceptional case for this late Italian’s hallucinatory modernism on this gripping, tripping collection.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

New York Polyphony, EndBeginning

New York Polyphony, endBeginning (Bis)

The fast-rising male a cappella quartet mixed luminous Flemish Renaissance works with a modern coda that didn’t sound at all out of place.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

Morton Feldman, Crippled Symmetry

Morton Feldman, Crippled Symmetry (Frozen Reeds)

Recorded 12 years ago and newly issued, this disc presented a live rendition of a luxuriantly enigmatic late work by Feldman, played by hand-picked collaborators.

 Buy on Amazon

Michael Mizrahi, The Bright Motion

Michael Mizrahi, The Bright Motion (New Amsterdam)

The NOW Ensemble pianist offered an illuminating mix of gorgeous, approachable recent works by Judd Greenstein, William Brittelle, Mark Dancigers and others, most of them written expressly for him.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

Anton Bruckner, Symphony No. 9

Anton Bruckner, Symphony No. 9 (EMI Classics)

Simon Rattle and his Berlin Philharmonic players capped a regal account of Bruckner’s unfinished final symphony with a recently completed finale of unique authority and potency.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

John Cage, The Works for Percussion 2

John Cage, The Works for Percussion 2 (Mode)

The Cage centenary brought no few worthy albums, but this commanding overview by Chicago’s Third Coast Percussion swept the field with technical precision, palpable groove and outstanding sound.

 Download on iTunes    Download on Amazon

The best events

Lauren Worsham in Dog Days
Photograph: James Matthew Daniel

Dog Days at Montclair State University

Composer David T. Little, librettist Royce Vavrek and director Robert Woodruff fashioned an unforgettable first full-length opera.

Einstein on the Beach
Photograph: Stephanie Berger

Einstein on the Beach at BAM

The groundbreaking Wilson/Glass collaboration returned in visionary triumph and unmistakable joy for Glass’s 75th birthday.

Song from the Uproar
Photograph: Paula Court

Song from the Uproar at the Kitchen

After years of growing up in public, Missy Mazzoli’s dreamlike opera lived up to great expectations and made a star of Abigail Fischer.

Brooklyn Village
Photograph: Laurie Olinder

Brooklyn Village at Roulette

Alan Pierson’s hardy Brooklyn Philharmonic mounted a heady paean to its home borough, both nostalgic and of the moment.

Photograph: Bobby Fisher

Yarn/Wire at Issue Project Room

This adventurous quartet proved the virtue of playing the field with a slate of unconventional commissions.

Philip Glass

Philip Glass Ensemble at the Park Avenue Armory

Nearly 40 years after its completion, Music in 12 Parts retained its vertiginous thrills in a fresh traversal by Glass and his band

Michael Tilson Thomas
Photograph: Terrence McCarthy

San Francisco Symphony at Carnegie Hall

Michael Tilson Thomas mixed a smoothie onstage as Jessye Norman typed—and John Cage was honored unforgettably.

David Lang
Photograph: Peter Serling

David Lang at Zankel Hall

The Pulitzer winner paired his heartbreakingly lovely Little Match Girl Passion with a provocative indie-rock gaze into Schubert's songful soul.

Mantra Percussion: Timber
Photograph: Lawrence Mesich

Mantra Percussion at BAM

Timber, Michael Gordon's tour de force for two-by-fours, mesmerized in a superhuman account by Mantra, deftly lit and amplified.
Philharmonic 360 at the Park Avenue Armory
Photograph: Chris Lee

Philharmonic 360 at the Park Avenue Armory

Placed last only because I missed it due to illness, this closely scrutinized, widely acclaimed event demanded citation for exemplifying Alan Gilbert's most daring ambitions for the Phil.

The worst

Deborah Voigt, featured in Der Ring des Nibelungen

The Metropolitan Opera Ring cycle

Despite genuinely impactful individual performances, seldom has so much hype, labor and money amounted to so little of substance.


    You may also like