Meet the Undateables: Marco and Elliot

Each week, we take two New Yorkers who swear they’re totally undateable, and put our matchmaking skills to the test

Will Gleason
Advertising

Undateables 1137

Why they’re single:
Marco: He prefers to be by himself.
Elliot: He travels a lot for work, which doesn’t always allow room for dating.

Ideal date:

Marco: A really intimate dinner and then a walk around the West Village.
Elliot: A nice dinner with appetizers, entrées and a bottle of wine.

THE DATE

First impression
Marco: “I got there early and was getting a little nervous, then in walks this really cute guy. I was like, Oh, I hope that’s him. Luckily, it was, and he seemed really kind and energetic.”
Elliot: “I was late and a little frazzled coming in. We met at the table, and he got up and said hello. Right away, I could tell he had a very pleasant and present demeanor.”

Chemistry
Marco: “He started talking to me like he’d known me for a long time, and we found out we’re in similar professions. I thought there was chemistry, definitely.” 
Elliot: “I’m not sure if we particularly vibed, but the two hours we had together were very enjoyable. He seemed like a good person with a good head on his shoulders.”

Awkward Moment
Marco: “There were literally none—not a single moment where I couldn’t think of what to say or anything. It felt really natural and great the entire night.
Elliot: “The only time I felt awkward was when I showed up 10 minutes late and then had to apologize to him. I’m usually a very punctual person.

Afterward
Marco: The night ended really smoothly. It was raining, so we were both leaving in cars. We exchanged numbers, and before he got into his car, we hugged goodbye.
Elliot: “We wanted to split the server’s tip, so we exchanged numbers via Venmo. I was trying to find a cab and then had to hop in one quickly, so I was like, ‘Hey, gotta go!’ 

Verdict
Marco: ♥♥It was just a good, really solid first date. He was really open and friendly—definitely one of the better dates I’ve had. I’m gonna text him for a second one.

Elliot: ♥♥ “I think we’re probably just friends, but I had a good time. It was nice meeting another human. He texted me this morning, but I wouldn’t say there’s a second date.

Our daters went to TGA NYC (320 W 36th St, tganyc.com)

RECOMMENDED: See more Undateables

Want to be set up on a free blind date? Email undateable@timeout.com.

Recommended
    You may also like
    You may also like
    Advertising