Frosting-filled cupcakes are the order of the day at this self-styled "all-American home-style bake shop," opened in 2006 by Susan Sarich to showcase her grandmother's recipes. Don't miss the whoopie pies or the banana pudding.
By far one of my favorite places to get a delicious (rather large) slice of cake. Stick with the cakes, they're better than the other desserts they carry. My favorite is the carrot cake, but you can't go wrong with any of their slices!