Karen's Toys

This shop's stock runs the gamut from classic to brand-new—adults will feel nostalgic while kids will run amok, checking out craft kits, eco-friendly options and a large selection of cute, smaller gifts like yo-yos, mad libs and bouncy balls perfect for stocking stuffers or party favor bags. The shop even has a music section! One of the best perks about Karen's is their gift wrapping—not only is it free, but it's expertly done, great for the holidays or if you're in a rush on the way to a birthday party. Tip: Check your local mail coupons or do a quick search online; you can almost always find a deal.