Get us in your inbox

Emerald Old Fashioned from Pouring Ribbons
Photograph: Jenny AdamsEmerald Old Fashioned from Pouring Ribbons

The 10 best cocktails you can make with Irish whiskey

DIY drinks to make at home with spicy-and-smooth Irish whiskey.

Written by
Meredith Heil
Time Out contributors

Like Champagne, Irish whiskey must meet a legal definition to carry its label. One paramount requirement is that it must be made in Ireland. It also has to be strong, though low and no-ABV Irish whiskey cocktails are possible. While you could tinker (hint: use less booze), these aren’t necessarily those options, but rather classic drinks and some novel spins created for NYC’s best Irish pubs that you can shake and stir at home. 

RECOMMENDED: Find more cocktails in NYC

10 cocktails to make

1. Irish Coffee

When it comes to quality Irish-inspired cocktails, look no further than an Irish coffee. Bartender Dale DeGroff created this recipe for Dead Rabbit, perfecting the sensational winter warmer and selecting the relatively obscure Clontarf 1014 Irish whiskey to serve as the drink’s base. Clontarf, a mild blended whiskey with a honey-sweet nose and flavors of oak and toasted almond, plays nicely with the coffee, warmed to a consistent 78 degrees Celsius to perfectly showcase the cocktail’s subtle layers. The real kicker here is the finish—a heavenly lid of hand-whipped cream that puts the mere thought of store-bought canisters to utter shame.

1½ oz blended Irish whiskey, preferably Clontarf 1014
4 oz coffee, preferably Caro De Minas Birch Coffee
½ oz demerara syrup
Heavy cream

Brew the coffee and pour it hot into an eight-ounce stemmed glass. Gently stir in the whiskey and demerara syrup. Hand whip the heavy cream so it pours smoothly, then carefully float a dollop on top of the coffee. 

2. The Irish Derby

This is a tart take on a Kentucky classic. The original Derby cocktail, first documented in 1947, called for bourbon, but a dose of smooth and citrusy Irish whiskey gives this cocktail a flavor profile fit for the fightin’ Irish. The fresh lime and fragrant curaçao enhance Redbreast whiskey’s pleasant dried fruit notes and herbal aroma, while the bitters temper the whiskey’s signature spicy, custardy finish. A snap to make, the brilliant orange Irish Derby looks particularly festive served up and garnished with a bright green twist of lime.

1½ oz Irish whiskey, preferably Redbreast
½ oz sweet vermouth
½ oz dry curaçao
½ oz fresh-squeezed lime juice
2 dashes of Angostura bitters
Lime twist for garnish

Load a cocktail shaker with ice and pour in the whiskey, vermouth, curaçao, lime juice and Angostura bitters. Shake hard for 30 seconds or until fully chilled, then strain into a cold cocktail glass and finish with a lime twist.


3. The Tommy Gun

This lively, tangy tipple was created in San Francisco by veteran mixologist Jacques Bezuidenhout in 2008 and has since gone on to appear on many a neo-speakeasy menu due to its unique ingredients, bold flavors and distinctive moniker. While just about any decent blended Irish whiskey would make a nice base, Jameson’s sharp, fruit-forward, open and oily mouthfeel proves a reliable backdrop for the fresh ginger’s harsh bite, the Grand Marnier’s rich citrus and the jam’s cloying sweetness.

2 oz Irish whiskey, preferably Jameson
½ oz Grand Marnier
2 thin slices ginger
1 tsp apricot jam
¼ oz fresh lemon juice
1 lemon twist

Toss the ginger, jam and lemon juice in a cocktail shaker. Muddle until thoroughly mixed. Fill the shaker with ice, whiskey and Grand Marnier and shake until chilled throughout. Strain well into a rocks glass filled with ice and garnish with a lemon twist.

4. Cork County Bubbles

County Cork has the distinction of being both the largest and second most populous county in Ireland. It also happens to be home to the Jameson distillery, birthplace of the famed Irish whiskey responsible for giving this refreshing, effervescent cocktail its dangerously boozy kick. An ounce of the nutty stuff delivers the perfect punch, while alpine-scented Chartreuse, honey syrup and zesty lemon work to brighten the whiskey’s dark-cherry undertones. It’s topped with dry, bubbly Champagne.

1 oz Irish whiskey, preferably Jameson 12 Year Old Special Reserve
¼ oz Yellow Chartreuse
½ oz fresh lemon juice
1½ tsp honey syrup
1 oz chilled Champagne
1 lemon twist

Pour the whiskey, Chartreuse, lemon juice and honey syrup into an ice-filled cocktail shaker and shake well. Strain into a frosty Champagne flute, top with Champagne and add a lemon twist for garnish.


5. The Psycho Killer

The Psycho Killer is yet another liquid opus from the master mixologists at New York City’s award-winning Dead Rabbit. Celebrated bar manager Jillian Vose came up with this curiously spiced, whiskey-spiked beverage, which combines mellow, fruity whiskey with bitter cocoa nib–infused Campari, silky creme de cacao, fragrant banana liqueur and a touch of absinthe to liven things up. While the Psycho Killer may require a bit more prep time than other drinks—the Campari needs at least an hour to properly soak up the cocoa nibs’ essence—a soothing sip of this deeply layered cocktail is worth the wait.

2 oz Irish whiskey, preferably Redbreast
¾ oz cocoa nib–infused Campari
½ oz creme de cacao
½ oz banana liqueur
2 dashes absinthe
3 tbsp cacao nibs
1 liter Campari

To infuse the Campari, pour the cocoa nibs into the bottle and let sit for at least an hour. When ready, strain to remove the nibs, then return the infused Campari to its bottle. Fill a tall mixing glass with ice and add all the ingredients. Stir well and strain into a classic Nick & Nora cocktail glass.

6. The Bitter Sweet

In summertime, there’s nothing quite like downing a cold beer cocktail on a warm day. Jameson’s inventive Irish cooler, a dynamic mix of piquant Campari, zesty pink grapefruit, effervescent Belgian white beer and Jameson Caskmates whiskey, a strong, sultry version of the original infused with mild dark chocolate and coffee notes. This fun, super-simple poolside sipper is guaranteed to set your impending barbecue apart from all others.

1½ oz whiskey, preferably Jameson Caskmates
1 oz Campari
1 oz pink grapefruit juice
3 oz Belgian white beer

Pour all ingredients into a chilled highball glass over ice and stir slowly with a bar spoon to combine.


7. Emerald Old-Fashioned

Joaquín Simó, the award-winning barkeep behind New York City’s top-tier Pouring Ribbons, perfected this Irish-inspired version of the beloved classic cocktail. To match the classic old-fashioned’s potency, Simó draws on Knappogue Castle 12 Year Old Irish whiskey, imbuing the drink with a complex medley of honeyed fruit and warm, peppery botanicals. A touch of the absinthe-like Dolin Génépy des Alpes paired with a teaspoon of appropriately hued Chartreuse stand in for sweet vermouth, adding a bright, intoxicating layer of minty euphoria to the mix that will keep drinkers glowing until the wee hours.

2 oz single-malt Irish whiskey, preferably Knappogue Castle 12 Year Old
1 tsp honey syrup (2 parts honey, 1 part water)
1 tsp Chartreuse
1 tsp Dolin Génépy des Alpes
1 sprig of fresh mint

Pour all ingredients into a rocks glass over ice. Stir until thoroughly chilled and garnish with fresh mint.

8. The South Side Smash

A take on the classic whiskey smash, the South Side Smash pays homage to the bourbon-based original by calling for woody, maple-scented Jameson Black Barrel, a traditional Irish whiskey aged in charred bourbon barrels. A few drops of herbaceous Fernet-Branca, ever a bartender’s favorite liqueur, adds to the cocktail’s intensity, while the fresh lime, simple syrup and muddled mint work to soften those boozy edges. Yes, it’s delicious, but proceed with caution—there’s a second reason it’s called a smash.

1½ oz Irish whiskey, preferably Jameson Black Barrel
½ oz Fernet-Branca
¾ oz fresh lime juice
1 oz simple syrup
5 to 8 leaves fresh mint; 1 sprig for garnish

Add whiskey, Fernet-Branca, lime juice, simple syrup, mint leaves and a cup of ice cubes to a cocktail shaker and shake hard for 30 to 40 seconds. Strain into a rocks glass over ice and garnish with the additional mint sprig.


9. The Irish Maid

The Irish Maid is a fantastic cocktail. The ingenious blend of bourbon-barrel aged whiskey, floral elderflower liqueur, sour lemon and bright cucumber make for a tart, expertly balanced and invigorating experience. Reminiscent of a classy whiskey sour, the Irish Maid is actually a riff on legendary Milk & Honey mixologist Sam Ross’ Kentucky Maid, the Derby-worthy cucumber-and-bourbon combo that took New York City’s cocktail scene by storm many years ago. 

1 oz Irish whiskey, preferably Jameson Black Barrel
½ oz elderflower liqueur, preferably St-Germain
¾ oz fresh lemon juice
¾ simple syrup
3 slices of cucumber

Drop the cucumber slices into an empty cocktail shaker and muddle until the juices are fully expressed. Fill the shaker with ice and add the remaining ingredients. Cap and shake strenuously, then strain into a rocks glass over ice. Garnish with a thin slice of cucumber and serve cold.

10. The Dusk Flip

Flips—a class of cocktails made with whole, raw eggs—can to be a tough sell when it comes to less experienced drinkers, but one taste of this indulgent after-dinner concoction is enough to convert even the most egg-averse of spirits enthusiasts. Luscious heavy cream, smashed blackberries and fluffy whipped egg lend the Dusk Flip its distinguishing lavender glow and dessert-worthy sweetness. A final sprinkling of nutmeg cuts through the sugar. This is an adult milkshake done right.

2 oz Irish whiskey
1 large egg
½ oz simple syrup
½ oz heavy cream
3 to 5 blackberries
A pinch of grated nutmeg

Muddle the blackberries in an empty cocktail shaker until well mashed. Add the whiskey, egg, simple syrup and heavy cream and shake vigorously. Pop open the shaker and fill with ice; shake the mixture for an additional 20 to 30 seconds. Fine-strain into a frosty Champagne coupe and top with nutmeg. Garnish with a fresh skewered blackberry.


    More on iconic eats

      You may also like
      You may also like