Jack the Horse Tavern

Bars, Cocktail bars Brooklyn Heights
Recommended
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • 4 out of 5 stars
(3user reviews)
31 Love It
Save it
Jack the Horse Tavern

Sitting on a leafy corner off Brooklyn Bridge Park, Jack the Horse Tavern is the embodiment of Brooklyn Heights chic: cool and picturesque with vintage flair. The brainchild of husband-wife duo chef Tim Oltmans (Tabla) and Micki Schubert, the restaurant touts airy storefront windows that peek onto a charming colonial streetscape of brick homes and shuttered windows while inside, a soft jazz soundtrack bids diners to ease into their surroundings and stay awhile.

Upgraded pub grub rules the day at this refreshed take on a local tavern, with flourishes highlighting the natural elegance of seasonal produce. The farm fresh beet salad ($10) is a harmonious symphony of red, golden and candy cane beets accented with goat cheese and a bitter hum from spindly twirls of cress. On the more indulgent side, a unique take on macaroni and cheese ($9) serves corkscrew cavatappi in a smoldering smoked gouda sauce.

On the entrees front, a well-charred flatiron steak ($29) is another fine example of the restaurant's upgrade of classic fare. The accompanying dollop of tarragon-flecked béarnaise is a classic bistro pairing for steak, while the prototypical steakhouse side of creamed spinach is surprisingly light here, barely kissed by a drape of melted butter. Crunchy flakes of sea salt give the dish a tactile quality that makes the meal a fully sensory experience. A side order of garlic-chive potato puree ($6) is perfectly silken with a green garlic flavor that evokes the verdant scents of a newly verdant farmer's market.

The strong bill of fare is bolstered by a terrific cocktail menu. The Arrangement ($12) is a boozy tour de force of mezcal, rye and falernum, a clove and almond-scented tiki bar staple. The juicy combination of blackberry, vodka and sauvignon blanc makes the Long Bottom Bramble ($10) a dangerously easy-drinking thirst quencher. And like at any worthy neighborhood tavern standby, half-priced specialty cocktails at happy hour are on offer to sweeten the deal, with small plates to fortify the stomach seven days a week.

BY: TIME OUT COMMUNITY REVIEWER OMAR TUNGEKAR

Posted:

Venue name: Jack the Horse Tavern
Contact:
Address: 66 Hicks St
Brooklyn
11201
Cross street: at Cranberry St
Opening hours: Mon-Sat 5:30pm-10:30pm; Sun 11am-3pm 5pm-9pm
Transport: Subway: A, C to High St; 2, 3 to Clark St
Price: Average cocktail: $10. AmEx, MC, V.
Do you own this business?
To improve this listing email: feedback@timeout.com

You may be interested in:

Average User Rating

3.7 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:0
  • 4 star:2
  • 3 star:1
  • 2 star:0
  • 1 star:0
LiveReviews|3
1 person listening
Gabrielle R

The food is great here and the location is even better.  Nestled in Brooklyn Heights on a quiet street, you get an instant neighborhood feeling when walking in. Great spot for the parents and prices aren't too bad either.

Evelyn D

Amazing food and a neat place. Feels very old-timey inside. Killer American fare, a little pricey but it'll be worth it!

allysonm
tastemaker

A hot spot in Brooklyn Heights for celeb-spotting (Mary Louise Parker and Jack Antonoff in the same night I was last there), Jack the Horse is also a cozy spot for gathering with girlfriends or a nice date out. The cocktails are well mixed and the dishes are delicious, particularly the seasonal risotto, the extra cheesy mac-n-cheese, and the 3-chocolate mousse.