John's Pizzeria

Restaurants, Pizza Midtown West
  • 4 out of 5 stars
(3user reviews)
7 Love It
Save it
John's Pizzeria
Caroline Voagen Nelson
John's Pizzeria

Got show tickets? Make a night of it and head to this spacious midtown spot, whose custom-made pies are big enough for little pizza lovers to share (or take home for tomorrow's lunch). With a menu full of Italian staples, John's makes it easy for tykes to delve into generous servings of baked ziti or eggplant parmigiana, both dripping with melted mozzarella. A slice of traditional New York cheesecake (a cliché, of course, but this is Times Square) is the perfect pretheater sweet-tooth fix. Remember your server—she just might be the next player you see on Broadway.


Venue name: John's Pizzeria
Address: 260 W 44th St
New York
Cross street: between Broadway and Eighth Ave
Transport: Subway: A, C, E to 42nd St–Port Authority; N, Q, R, 42nd St S, 1, 2, 3, 7 to 42nd St–Times Sq
Price: Average pie: $14. Average main course: $12.
Do you own this business?
To improve this listing email:

Average User Rating

4 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:0
  • 4 star:3
  • 3 star:0
  • 2 star:0
  • 1 star:0
1 person listening

John's Pizzeria claims to have the best pizza in New York, as does any other pizza place in the city. Are they the best? Not sure. Are they good? Damn good. Brick oven pizza cooked to perfection, tomato sauce, and cheese that stretches with a little bit of basil. Mwah. Crust is crisp and the ingredients taste really fresh. Took the pizza to go since the Bleecker St. location was packed, but will try to come back and sit down for a pie. The decor looked so cool!

Stephen L

I've been going to John's Pizzeria at the original two-room Bleecker St. location for decades. When they became hella-popular (probably due to a Time Out bump!) and started expanding, I thought that would be the end of what had been the best pizza in NYC. But I was wrong. The theater district location is housed in a large space, formerly a church, so it can be loud and crowded, but the food hasn't suffered. The freshest ingredients are used just like downtown, and the ovens must be the same too, since the crust is perfectly done every time. A fun place for a group or a couple. But, of course, no slices!

jen s

I personally prefer their location in the village, but this is great for a meal before a show. Great pizza, and pretty good salads as well. Location is perfect for Broadway shows, and it's a really big, fun space. The kids got a dessert shaped like a teddy bear head that was a huge hit!