L&B Spumoni Gardens

This Bensonhurst original has served one of the best Sicilian slices in town since 1939. Sweetish tomato sauce is generously slathered over tall, doughy squares with crunchy undersides and topped with with melty mozzarella and Parm. It's a classic treat to eat out in L&B's large outdoor space, and there's a full-service operation inside with a lengthy red sauce menu, too.