Lobster Place

Restaurants , Seafood Chelsea
Recommended
  • 4 out of 5 stars
  • 4 out of 5 stars
(2 user reviews)
26 Love It
Save it
Lobster Place
Photograph: Max Flatow
Lobster Place
More than just boutique fish market, the Lobster Place is also a thriving seafood wholesaler that has been servicing many of the city’s top restaurants for over 40 years. Amidst tanks of live seafood and spreads of various grab-and-go goods (lobster rolls, take-out sushi) at the Chelsea Market outpost, however, lies a 20-seat raw-fish counter touting one of the most well-priced tasting menus in town. 
 

Omakase, the ubiquitous Japanese term used in chef's choice dining, literally translates to: “Chef, I’m in your hands.” Here, the nimble hands are those of executive sushi chef Subhash Gurung, who is as quick with a smile as he is with his filet knife. Omakase dinners frequently top $100 per person at the city’s more high-end Japanese counters, but here you can indulge for the relative bargain of a well-spent $65.

After a hot towel, sip of sake and requisite miso soup, you’re ready to begin the show. On a recent night, live shrimp was dismembered before diners, the head tossed in a fryer and the tail, still pulsing, deveined and topped with a thimble of roe and wasabi. The two halves were reunited seconds later on a plate that also included sashimi of abalone, giant clam and amberjack. That two-way shrimp highlights a favorite theme of Gurung’s: showcasing a single seafood through various preparations and cuts. From there, you might progress to fluke with bonito flakes, red snapper with lime juice, seared salmon belly with a teardrop of mayo or yellow-tail with yuzu and shiso leaves.

Among the more unique courses pits California uni (sea urchin), large and custardy, against Japanese uni, more petite, creamy and sweet by comparison. If and when it arrives, the most spectacular offering triples up on Bluefin tuna in distinct forms: akami, the lean, bright red, ubiquitous side cut; chutoro, the dull pink, richer belly cut; and otoro, the fattiest, palest and most prized cut of tuna belly. A morsel of otoro is a quasi-religious experience with meat so unbelievably delicate as to practically evaporate from your tongue.

An omakase experience at The Lobster Place’s sushi bar proves that fine dining need not come with all the rote accouterments. In the background din of the power washers and the austerity of the surrounding white tile there is a profound authenticity and satisfaction that comes with eating incredibly fresh seafood inside a bustling fish market.

BY: TIME OUT COMMUNITY REVIEWER MICHAEL PEARSON

Venue name: Lobster Place
Contact:
Address: Chelsea Market
75 Ninth Ave
New York
10011
Cross street: at 16th St
Opening hours: Mon–Sat 9:30am–9pm; Sun 10am–8pm
Transport: Subway: A, C, E to 14th St; L to Eighth Ave
Price: Omakase: $65
Do you own this business?

Average User Rating

3.5 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:0
  • 4 star:1
  • 3 star:1
  • 2 star:0
  • 1 star:0
LiveReviews|2
1 person listening
Chris R

This is an average place for Chelsea (because there are so many options), but above average seafoody cafeteria in general.  Like a cafeteria, the food is on display right there for you to see.  It's on the fresher side, as far a cafeterias go, though.  The prices are actually fine.  A place called the Lobster Place sounds potentially expensive.  Add Chelsea Market to the mix and it definitely sounds like no bargain.  But I'd say there are bargains to be had here that taste good enough, and if you're willing to actually crack into some lobster (seating situation sucks - it's just the over-crowded public seating in the CM hallway), it's not only good, but it's fairly affordable!

@bellafranchi
tastemaker

Fresh Seafood, YES PLEASE!! not only are the lobster rolls to die for but the fresh clams and oysters make me jump for joy. I enjoy a place where you can get shrimps and clam chowder, and also take home some great goodies to have at home. It is also located inside of the chelsea market which makes it the perfect Sunday outing if you want to hang out with friends and family. Check out the other vendors but The Lobster Place will grab your attention and keep it.