Worldwide icon-chevron-right North America icon-chevron-right United States icon-chevron-right New York State icon-chevron-right New York icon-chevron-right Beacon’s Closet

Beacon’s Closet

Shopping, Boutiques Greenpoint
4 out of 5 stars
(5user reviews)
Beacon's Closet, stores
Beacon's Closet

Carrie Peterson’s buy/sell/trade store has become a household name in the city since establishing outposts in Park Slope and Greenwich Village, but the original Williamsburg store wass still a prime spot to scope preworn treasures. It has since moved to Greenpoint because the store's landlord didn't renew its lease. "The neighborhood has grown at astronomical rates," Peterson says. Luckily the rent rates are friendlier—for now—in Greenpoint, which is nice considering this new outpost is only six-and-a-half blocks away from its old spot. Expect the same vibe and budget-friendly prices on vintage goods that Beacon's is known for. Sifting through the many racks of gently used clothing for true finds can require a heck of a lot of patience, but the effort is well worth it for fashionistas on a budget. On a recent visit, we spotted a pair of Manolo Blahnik peep-toe pumps ($22) and a Patrizia Pepe china silk tunic ($50); dudes’ duds included a Club Monaco denim jacket ($17) and Sperry Top-Siders ($19). Looking to sell your own cast-offs? Clean, gently-used duds are inspected on the spot for their resale value (which is determined by seasons or what the store needs stocked). You’ll receive either a percentage of the resale value in cash (35 percent) or store credit (55 percent) to put toward your next purchase.


Venue name: Beacon’s Closet
Address: 74 Guernsey St
Cross street: at Nassau Ave
Opening hours: Mon–Sun 11am–8pm
Transport: Subway: G to Nassau Ave
Price: $$
Do you own this business?
Static map showing venue location

Average User Rating

3.7 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:2
  • 4 star:2
  • 3 star:1
  • 2 star:0
  • 1 star:1
1 person listening

For a consignment store, Beacon is pretty great. Very hit or miss but that is of course to be expected. I have found some great designer pieces for very low prices (compared to what they'd retail for). As far as selling goes, Beacon is very selective, which shows in the inventory. 


I sell clothes at thrift shops often, though I never really find anything worth buying with store credit.  I was really surprised when I found a handful of pieces that I wanted at Beacon's Closet.  Their selection was really impressive - I found a Kate Spade top and Alice + Olivia romper which were BOTH major steals!  Their buyers have great taste and an eye for great brands.  Since it was my first time, the buyers (very nicely) explained how they look at potential buys and were helpful in guiding me through the store.  Can't wait to go back! 

Rough day at Beacons closet.  I have been a regular visitor of Beacons Closet since they opened their doors a few years ago near my abode in Chelsea.  Other than the occasionally dismissive floor person attitude (as depicted in Broad City)  I've traded there and shopped there many times without incident.  Until today.  Today, I was so rudely treated I dare never step foot in that store again sans an apology.  I hadn't found anything to my liking and thought the spree a wash until I happened upon a designer bag I favored.  As I waited while my friend
tried on clothes, a shop girl approached me saying did I find that bag over there.  Without really realizing where she was pointing or why she was asking, I said yeah.  She proceeded to say that the bag I had was on hold for another customer.  Realizing, I told her that it hadn't been on hold, I had found it on the floor. This is where things went awry.  Instead of acknowledging that OK, yes maybe it wound up on the floor  but it was supposed to be on hold and would I concede it back to the other customer, she commenced to insinuate that I had not found the bag where I said I had.  She did this several times.  Now, I could care less about the bag,  I was too shocked that this disrespectful employee was questioning my integrity and disregarding my offense as a customer to be in so many words accused of lying, publicly!  By this point our exchange had become a confrontation and  I was thoroughly offended by the level of disrespect.  Other staff came near including the self described owner of the store, Beth Moon.  She immediately supported her employee who had been completely wrong and offered more cattiness and dismissiveness.  She did not care what happened or that I was upset. One employee suggested we view the video surveillance of which I said, Yes!  Please, view the tape and then come back to me with an apology.  I implored them to view the tape?  Confirm that I had been telling the truth and acknowledge how rude and disrespectful it is to accuse someone of being dishonest?  This is how you treat your customers? We are dispensible?  By this point they were making jokes, snickering, demanding me to leave, denying any wrong doing.  Of course they did not view the tape.  I was so incensed by their ill treatment.  Not even the store owner, Beth Moon (I came to look up on the website) offered any fair or balanced consideration.   I promised I would write a letter to headquarters.  She said, well I will look forward to your letter.  So I am instead writing this letter to the internet, hopefully someone holds them accountable for their disrespect and disregard.  How you treat people matters more than anything else in this world, I won't be disrespected without consequence.  Beacons, you need a wake up call, you tout being an all female company based in Brooklyn yet your were horribly degrading to long time women customer, this coming from a true Native New Yorker.  Unacceptable and supremely wack.

Please note that the new address in Greenpoint is 74 Guernsey, not 64.  Thank you so much for the interest!