Get us in your inbox


Judge and Jury

  • Restaurants
  • Old Street
  • price 2 of 4

Time Out says

A British restaurant within Shoreditch’s Courthouse Hotel.

After a £40 million revamp, the Grade II-listed Old Street magistrates’ court and police station has been transformed into a second branch of the Courthouse Hotel.

Clearly keen to capitalise on the building’s heritage, the restaurant – housed in the old courtroom – has been decked out with courthouse memorabilia and the walls are lined with paintings of a bizarre selection of celebrities as court judges (the motley crew includes Ray Winstone, Paloma Faith and Martine McCutcheon). It’s a bit tacky, which is a shame given the site’s history – Ronnie and Reggie Kray appeared here at their first criminal hearing in 1965.

The atmosphere was a little lacking, too. There were only four tables occupied on a Friday night, yet somehow the lamb rump on the menu (one of the better sounding options) wasn’t available. I opted for a monkfish curry instead, but the fish was dry, and the sauce was overpowered by spice and lacked depth of flavour. Better was the slow-cooked pork belly starter, served with a squash purée, though the skin could have been crisper. It was all a bit underwhelming and overpriced (£4.95 for steamed rice!).

In an area saturated with places to eat, the Judge & Jury is best placed as a convenient stop-off for hotel guests, but little else.

Isabelle Aron
Written by
Isabelle Aron


335-337 Old Street
Tube: Old Street.
Dinner for two with drinks and service: around £95
Do you own this business?
Sign in & claim business
You may also like
    Bestselling Time Out offers