Worldwide icon-chevron-right Europe icon-chevron-right United Kingdom icon-chevron-right England icon-chevron-right London icon-chevron-right Vicoli di Napoli Pizzeria

Vicoli di Napoli Pizzeria

Restaurants, Pizza Stoke Newington
4 out of 5 stars
3 out of 5 stars
(12user reviews)
 (Photo: Andy Parsons)
1/6
Photo: Andy Parsons
 (Photo: Andy Parsons)
2/6
Photo: Andy Parsons
 (Photo: Andy Parsons)
3/6
Photo: Andy Parsons
 (Photo: Andy Parsons)
4/6
Photo: Andy Parsons
 (Photo: Andy Parsons)
5/6
Photo: Andy Parsons
 (Photo: Andy Parsons)
6/6
Photo: Andy Parsons

Time Out says

4 out of 5 stars

A London branch of the Neapolitan pizza joint made famous in ‘Eat, Pray, Love’.

Please note, Vicoli di Napoli Pizzeria was previously called L’antica Pizzeria da Michele. Time Out Food editors, May 2019.

The shabby naples joint of L’antica Pizzeria da Michele, open since 1906, is much hyped as ‘the best pizza in the world’. Fanning the flames of that rep was the 2010 film ‘Eat Pray Love’, where Julia Roberts sits all blissed out, declaring she’s ‘having a relationship’ with her pizza.

Well, lucky old us, because the Naples original has just spawned its first international branch in Stoke Newington. A much less shabby, bright blue establishment on Church Street to be precise – and the whole of the capital is in the queue. First things first: L’antica really is amazing, but if you’re looking for a relationship with this pizza it’s going to take some commitment.

Not only do you usually have to queue for at least 40 minutes to get a slice of the action, but once you fight your way in, the menu is the pizza equivalent of monogamy (well, Mormon-style monogamy, at any rate). There are just two varieties – marinara and margherita – or you could argue three, if you count the double mozzarella margherita on its own. But you can definitely forget about having any bits on the side – when my date asked for a condiment (which shall remain unnamed) the waitress looked like she was going to ask us to leave.

And good thing too, because when something’s this delicious you don’t need any distractions. Thin, crispy and served with beautiful burnt bubbles in the dough, what makes L’antica’s pizza really special is its softness. No exaggeration, you can cut through this base with the edge of a fork, and it comes so saucy and voluptuous you actually have to cradle each piece with both hands to keep things together. The sauce itself is exceptional: best appreciated on the marinara (just tomato, garlic and oregano), it’s fresh and sweet and just a little bit tart. Best of the two (three?), though, is the double mozzarella. Properly luscious, it arrives bigger than the plate it’s served on and oozes puddles of wonderfully stringy cheese. Order this and you will understand what got Julia Roberts so hot under the collar – it really is love at first bite.

But the best pizza in the world? If no one had told me this before I went, I’d probably be more blown away – a rep like that can only set you up for disappointment. So (slightly) lower your expectations and go on a weekday lunchtime to avoid the queue. This slice is definitely worth pulling a sickie for.

Details

Address: 125 Stoke Newington Church St
London
N16 0UH
Transport: Stoke Newington Rail
Price: Dinner for two with drinks and service: around £40.
Contact:
Do you own this business?

Users say (12)

3 out of 5 stars

Average User Rating

3.4 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:2
  • 4 star:4
  • 3 star:4
  • 2 star:1
  • 1 star:1
LiveReviews|12
1 person listening
1 of 1 found helpful

I am sorry but this is very overestimated. This is not the authentic italian Pizza as they put Pecorino on top of the pizza and the pasta is not the same as the origynal Da michele in Naples. I was very disappointed when I tried it. The staff is also very rude and super slow. I am italian and I won't be back in this place. There is plenty of other italian authentic pizza in the city.

Tastemaker

Nice enough pizza (the dough was great) but I'm afraid I do agree with the below reviews saying it is a bit over-hyped. It's definitely not bad at all - soft, chewy base, good size - but there were only 5 pizzas to choose from, and it definitely wasn't the best pizza I've ever had. The house wine was a little expensive at £28 a bottle, but it was really nice. The pizzas themselves were all reasonably priced, less than £10 each.


Completely overrated.  It's just plain boring, and that's even worse than if it were bad-but-interesting.

tastemaker

I thought the pizza was quite average here. The dough was nice and definitely passes the "will it tip" test when you hold up a slice. But I much prefer the sauce at the pizzeria in the Italian market at Elephant and Castle, and I do like a bit more variety in the toppings like Pizza Pilgrims. I think it's great that they are made famous by Eat Pray Love but I'm not sure this location is producing the same quality as their Naples original. It's a real bummer as we were hoping this would become one of our regulars. 

Tastemaker

My agree closely mirrors Alex below. I really wanted to love the pizza here as well. As a NY pizza snob, my pizza standards are crazy high. I got the margarita for takeaway.

Is the dough good with an appropriate chew factor? Yes. The sauce? Tasty and nicely spread. But... it's burned pizza. The bottom was so charcoaled that was the overwhelming flavour.

I'd return to Pizza East, Joe's in Clapham and Yard Sale any day over this place.


As I really wanted to try this place, Iwas ready to travel all the way to Stoke Newington and to face the prospect of queuing. I went on a Saturday night at around 8pm and I've got a table after an hour. The waiting wasn't that bad as there is a pub just opposite and you receive a text when your table is ready. I really enjoyed the pizza as I think tasted very 'authentic' but there are other places in London just as good. Don't expect a big menu as all you can order really is two kinds of pizza - margherita or marinara - and a beer, but overall very good value for money and a very Italian experience. 


Oh I wanted to love this place so much. After reading everything about it online and seeing the film I was so ready to go here.. I had held off for a few months as not living by Stokey it seemed a little far - however last week we managed to combine a trip round the park and an afternoon of pizza. 


From the outside it looks all I wanted and more and inside we (miraculously!) didn't even have to queue. The three of us all ordered the double margarita and sat back waiting in anticipation. I was absolutely determined to love it. I feel like I know my pizza and I wasn't put off by a lack of ingredients or choices - having been to Naples a number of times I thought this would be a pizza -based dream come true.

Look, it's an above average pizza. It's large, crispy on the outside and gooey in the middle. But it just wasn't the pizza epiphany I was looking for. I found the sauce a little dull, pools of liquid in the middle, and the charcoaled outsides a little overbearing. I like the thin, slightly burnt pizzas, I like soggy middles and and I was looking for the authentic sauce, but it was just too much of all of it and not enough flavour. I've absolutely had better pizzas in London, and no doubt in Italy... if I lived locally then sure, it's good pizza, but for me it just didn't live up to the hype.

tastemaker

When I heard the news that this Pizzeria is coming to London I couldn’t quite believe it.
After reading the book and watching the movie ‘Eat, pray , love’  I was one of those suckers that actually wanted to fly to Napoli just to get a taste of that pizza. I didn’t manage to go yet but whenever I talked to anyone that comes from there or has visited the city- I always ask them- have you been to the pizzeria??

Imagine my disbelief and excitement when I heard the same exact pizzeria will open right under my nose in Stokey? How very nice of them to do that, very handy for us Londoners!
I avoided first week of opening because-English people love to cue but I’m not about that life.
I tried my luck the following week and I was successful! Managed to get a table and order the much anticipated, much talked about pizza, supposedly one of the best ones in the world.

When it came to our table I thought to myself ‘’Is that it?’’ I don’t know what exactly I expected. Confetti falling from the ceiling once it arrives? But after first few bites it all made sense. It was heavenly. Saying goes that you can judge if pizza is truly good, by having a Margarita, and I agree with that. This pizza didn’t need any fancy extras of dried tomatoes or anchovies. It was simple cheese, basil and tomato but it was exquisite.

My friend and I were mumbling ‘’ Mmmm I love pizza’’ to each other with mouthful of this perfect Italian invention.

Tastemaker

I think I went to this place with extremely high expectations, and I was a bit disappointed! I am a massive fan of the original place in Naples where yes, you can definitelly find the best pizza in the world, no doubt about it. However I felt like something was "missing" in the London branch...not quite sure what? Pizza was okay, but not any better than Pizza Pilgrims or Mercato Metropolitano (my absolute favourite). I strongly suggest you to choose the larger Marinara, it's the original pizza and the tomato sauce is extremely yummy.


I want to keep my faith and think that the guys just need to get used to the oven, the water and the bad weather here...and will go back in a few months to give this place another chance!

0 of 1 found helpful
tastemaker

Believe the hype. My long awaited visit was Pizzalicious! Dropped a point for choosing such a tiny restaurant to inhabit though. I’m a local and the queues have only just subsided after a year. I would be annoyed to travel more than the 100metres from my front door to have to wait in the rain! However, once inside it still feels a little cramped. Upsize needed for maximum pizza enjoyment!

0 of 1 found helpful

Named by journalists as “the sacred temple of pizza,” after my visit I can certainly see why.

No wonder Julia Roberts playing Elizabeth Gilbert fell in love with pizza in Eat Pray Love.

Following the recent trend of single and dual dish restaurants, the menu had only two pizzas available; Margherita and Marinara.

The dough was light and chewy with the correct consistency of tomato and cheese; not too overpowering. The ‘fior di late’ mozzarella had a unique milky flavour. This is a speciality of the Agerola area, that is renowned for its cheese.

The black forest cake which was from the only two choices on the menu was perfectly moist and chocolatey.

My main criticism would be that the decoration was very basic and the service could have been improved. Overall, the pizza is of the highest quality at surprisingly low prices of less than £10.00 per head excluding drinks. So queues for getting into the most in-demand pizzeria in London are certainly justified.

The chefs who having been trained in Naples are undoubtedly recreating authentic pizzas. Not only would I recommend this restaurant but it is a must for pizza lovers everywhere.

0 of 1 found helpful
tastemaker

Was finally able to live out my Eat, Pray, Love fantasies and eat at L'Antica Pizzeria da Michele. As far as the pizza goes, it's solid stuff. For an incredibly good value, you get a massive pie, which tastes like pizza should taste (a perfectly ooey gooey marriage of dough, marinara and mozarella) and will leave you feeling full and content. Would highly recommend washing it down with a Moretti too. Is it the best pizza in London though? Do you want to be in a relationship with this pizza like Liz? Unfortunately I have to echo the below sentiments and say no, probably not. Is it still a pretty delish-yet-overhyped pizza however, and maybe if people came here without mad fantasies and expectation (like me...) they'd be a bit happier about what they ate. Service is ok. We booked over the phone and were told upon arrival they didn't take bookings so that was pretty confusing and no one seemed sure what to do with us but we eventually got seated and there were no more issues from that point onward.


Snap up exclusive discounts in London

Time Out's handpicked deals — hurry, they won't be around for long...