Worldwide icon-chevron-right Europe icon-chevron-right United Kingdom icon-chevron-right England icon-chevron-right London icon-chevron-right ‘Groan Ups’ review

‘Groan Ups’ review

Theatre, Comedy Vaudeville Theatre , Strand Until Sunday December 1 2019
2 out of 5 stars
 (© Robert Day)
1/7
© Robert Day Jonathan Sayer (Simon), Henry Shields (Archie), Charlie Russell (Katie), Henry Lewis (Spencer), Nancy Zamit (Moon)
 (© Robert Day)
2/7
© Robert Day
 (© Robert Day)
3/7
© Robert Day Charlie Russell (Katie), Henry Shields (Archie), Nancy Zamit (Moon), Jonathan Sayer (Simon)
 (© Robert Day)
4/7
© Robert Day Henry Lewis (Spencer), Henry Shields (Archie), Charlie Russell (Katie)
 (© Robert Day)
5/7
© Robert Day Henry Lewis (Spencer), Henry Shields (Archie)
 (© Robert Day)
6/7
© Robert Day Henry Shields (Archie), Dave Hearn (Paul), Henry Lewis (Spencer)
 (© Robert Day)
7/7
© Robert Day Nancy Zamit (Moon), Jonathan Sayer (Simon), Bryony Corrigan (Chemise)

Time Out says

2 out of 5 stars

The folks behind ‘The Play That Goes Wrong’ fall flat on their faces with this oft-cringey school-set comedy

The members of Mischief Theatre could presumably have all retired at 30 on the proceeds of their sleeper smash ‘The Play That Goes Wrong’, the sparky backstage farce that’s been ensconced in the West End for five years.

In fact, the core company – who’ve been together for 11 years, since they met at drama school – have noticeably failed to rest on their laurels. When they’ve not been busy breaking America with their first hit, they’ve found the time to produce seasonal variant ‘Peter Pan Goes Wrong’ and stand-alone smash ‘The Comedy About a Bank Robbery’, while Penn & Teller collab ‘Magic Goes Wrong’ will be with us in the new year.

They’re a genuinely heartening success story with an impressive work ethic and it’s a real shame that their new play ‘Groan Ups’ is fairly dreadful.

The group have absolutely nailed the whole posh-people-getting-flustered-at-stuff-breaking thing, but ‘Groan Ups’ – which follows a group of five friends from primary school to adulthood – feels like their attempt to do a ‘proper’ play, and fairly brutally exposes their weaknesses.

In the first half of Kirsty Patrick Ward’s production, the adult performers play children, first aged around six, then around 13 (weirdly they seem to be at the same school for all of this). Now I can confirm that children can be pretty funny, but the dialogue here suggest Mischief are aware what children are but have never met any. An opening sequence in which the class make an inadvertently smutty presentation about their weekends is absolutely ghastly, all sub-‘Confessions of a Window Cleaner’ innuendo; as teenagers everyone talks like a group of particularly egregious middle managers on a bonding weekend: throughout they act like dim, lairy adults, devoid of the innocence and eccentricity of childhood. 

In the second half, it’s the school reunion, and the thirtysomething cast get to act their ages. The script – by performers Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields – is much less excruciating, but it still clunks sway. The big revelation of who has been harbouring an unrequited crush for who has been aggressively signposted since the first act, and there are all sorts of wearyingly crass assumptions about class and sexuality.

That it’s basically well-meaning is never in doubt; neither is the fact that Mischief are terrific with a silly quip (the recurring gag about the names of the school pets is very amusing), or that they’re on stronger ground whenever it becomes more farce-like. They are a fundamentally likeable bunch. But they blunder way outside their comfort zone with the child acting in the first half and again with the bittersweet dramedy stuff in the second, and it just doesn’t work. And while I'm all for performers shooting for the moon, I’d argue that if you’re going out of your comfort zone trying to make what’s essentially a cheapo Richard Curtis knock-off, it’s not a particularly noble failure. 

Details

Venue name: Vaudeville Theatre
Address: 404
Strand
London
WC2R 0NH
Transport: Tube: Embankment/Covent Garden
Price: £20-£75. Runs 2hr 45min

Dates And Times

Users say

LiveReviews|0
1 person listening

Snap up exclusive discounts in London

Time Out's handpicked deals — hurry, they won't be around for long...