‘True West’ review

Theatre, Drama
3 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars
(4user reviews)
 (© Marc Brenner)
1/9
© Marc Brenner Kit Harington & Johnny Flynn
 (© Marc Brenner)
2/9
© Marc Brenner Donald Sage MacKay, Johnny Flynn & Kit Harington
 (© Marc Brenner)
3/9
© Marc Brenner Johnny Flynn & Kit Harington
 (© Marc Brenner)
4/9
© Marc Brenner Johnny Flynn & Kit Harington
 (© Marc Brenner)
5/9
© Marc Brenner Johnny Flynn
 (© Marc Brenner)
6/9
© Marc Brenner Kit Harington & Johnny Flynn
 (© Marc Brenner)
7/9
© Marc Brenner Kit Harington & Johnny Flynn
 (© Marc Brenner)
8/9
© Marc Brenner Kit Harington
 (© Marc Brenner)
9/9
© Marc Brenner Madeleine Potter 

Kit Harrington and Johnny Flynn star as warring brothers in Sam Shepard's moody desert drama

Kit Harington: ‘I f**king hate snootiness in the theatre’

In the first ever West End outing for the late Sam Shepard’s 1980 classic, Kit Harington plays Austin, a screenwriter house-sitting for his mother while she’s away in Alaska. If you bought a ticket because he looked hot in ‘Game of Thrones’, you might be disappointed, because in ‘True West’ he’s kitted out like an ’80s porn mogul living in a suburban witness protection programme. 

As Austin works doggedly away at the typewriter, pausing only to water his mother’s plants like a good boy, he’s interrupted by the arrival of Lee (Johnny Flynn). Despite being the ‘successful’ one of the family, Austin is bullied by his older, cowboy shirt-wearing brother, who derails Austin’s latest project and sells his own hee-hawing western flick to the producer instead.

On paper, and to some extent on stage, Shepard’s premise is pretty fascinating. There’s a lot happening here with warring (and wounded) masculinities, particularly how Austin’s achievements in a metro elite career don’t prevent him being trounced by his loudmouth, swaggering sibling.

And then there’s the storytelling aspect. Shepard’s fighting brothers have a mythical or biblical edge, a modern-day Cain and Abel or Romulus and Remus. The stories they’re writing are, in turn, also fables. Lee’s ‘true west’ script is based on an invented idea of the good ol’ U.S. of A., one filled with cattle trucks, car chases and wife-stealing ranch hands.

But Matthew Dunster’s production sells it a bit short. The celeb pairing of Harington and Flynn never fizzes enough with the threat of violence. Hair and make-up aside, both remain slightly too young, too pretty and too reserved to work in either role.

Most of the tension comes from prolonged shouting or loud blasts of twanging, drum-thumping music during scene changes. But even as they’re trashing the room, smashing objects and downing whiskey, the whole thing has the feel of an undergrad party where everyone’s pretending to ‘GO KERRRRAAAZZZY!!!’ in the most controlled way possible. And that’s never a story to remember.

By: Rosemary Waugh

Posted:

Average User Rating

4 / 5

Rating Breakdown

  • 5 star:0
  • 4 star:4
  • 3 star:0
  • 2 star:0
  • 1 star:0
LiveReviews|4
2 people listening
tastemaker

The theme for this play is really interesting, it could easily slip into a humdrum family drama but the dialogue and the acting keep it moving along. Johnny Flynn and Kit Harrington are excellent and the scene in the second half with the toasters is comedy gold. In the last few scenes where the mother appears the play lost steam for me and just veers off to a strange ending that didn't feel completely satisfying. 

tastemaker

Kit Harrington plays a Screenwriter working on his latest project in the Desert, he is joined by his disruptive brother (Johnny Flynn) who sees an opportunity to make a lot of money very easily. I found the first act rather slow & lacking in energy. The second act really takes off and both Harrington & Flynn give their all to the production. I thought it was hilarious & delivered a real punch.


Quibbles with some aspects of the play itself, the direction and particularly the intensity and brilliance of the two leads lifts this close to 5 star territory. A brave choice of play - wordy and often obtuse, but in such safe hands as Harrington and Flynn, it sizzles in parts. Recommended for those who like to see real star power at work.

Tastemakertastemaker

What did I just see? I don’t know. I never saw Sam Shepard’s plays before, so I don’t know if True West is typical of him or that’s the directorial vision taking over.

The events that start out as a story of a dysfunctional family, of two brothers who couldn’t be more different from each other, to be precise, veer into absurdity very quickly. It became obvious soon enough that the grotesque Western plot line, imagined by one of the brothers (Johnny Flynn’s character) and that became the stepping stone for their escalating conflict when it got picked up for production by a heavyweight producer, is not nearly as absurd as the other brother (Kit Harrington’s character) claimed. Truth is stranger than fiction, true westerns can often play out in our homes. Is that what Sam Shepard was trying to say? Like I said earlier, I don’t know. But I guess the fact that the 2 hours passed in the blink of an eye, with no moment that felt boring or unnecessary (and this is a heavily dialogue based play that is built around only 4 characters) is the testament to Shepard’s, the director’s and actors’ skill.