News

Broadway review: The Fantasticks (★★★★) makes new magick

Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt's once-musty musical gets refreshed with a blast of young same-sex romance.

Adam Feldman
Written by
Adam Feldman
Theater and Dance Editor, Time Out USA
Nathan Levy, Maxim Chlumecky in The Fantasticks
Photograph: Courtesy Joan Marcus | The Fantasticks
Advertising

Broadway review by Adam Feldman
Rating: Rating: ★★★★ (firmly recommended)
Ticketing: Buy tickets here

That Second Stage Theater’s production of The Fantasticks marks the show’s Broadway debut seems rather fantastical in and of itself. After all, Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt’s romantic bauble has played in New York City nearly continuously since 1960: Its 42-year engagement at downtown’s Sullivan Street Theatre made it the longest-running musical of all time (a record it still holds, though the West End Les Miz will break it soon), and it returned in 2006 for a nine-year residency near Times Square at the shabby Snapple Theater Center. But those were Off Broadway venues; it was unclear whether this cozy little show could work in a larger house, or indeed whether anyone should try. “The end of its run is like the death of a great-aunt—considered very pretty in her day!—for whom you have an abiding fondness, even though, to be honest, you haven’t visited her in ages,” I wrote at the close of the tourist-trap revival, which smelled vaguely of mothballs and cloying perfume. “It is time now to let The Fantasticks take its rightful place: in history.”

Well, consider my words eaten. The charming new Broadway incarnation of The Fantasticks, lovingly directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, has roots in the show’s storied past; Jason Sherwood’s set begins with a ghost-lit evocation of the original Off Broadway run. But it plants itself firmly in the present, and comes to unexpected bloom. “I thought I had planted a turnip or at worst perhaps an avocado: something remotely useful,” says one of the musical’s parents, using a gardening metaphor to describe her rather exotic child. “What need do I have for a rose?” But we all could use a rose right now. The Fantasticks is a bouquet.  

Zane Phillips in The Fantasticks
Photograph: Courtesy Joan MarcusThe Fantasticks

And it only took a sex change! Tom Jones’s original libretto, adapted from Edmund Rostand's 1894 French comedy The Romanesques, depicted the ostensibly forbidden romance between a boy named Matt and a girl named Luisa, whose feuding fathers build a wall to keep them apart, as in the Pyramus and Thisbe story staged by the Rude Mechanicals in A Midsummer Night’s Dream. In reality, the fathers are in cahoots, using reverse psychology to make their offspring fall in love; they even hire a professional fake kidnapper named El Gallo to pretend to abduct Luisa, so that Matt can appear to save her. But the young couple’s love is tested in Act II, when the parents’ machinations are exposed. That plot remains on Broadway, but with a set of new pronouns: In the substantially revised script that Jones devised before his death in 2023, Luisa has become a boy named Lewis, and the fathers have morphed into mothers. 

Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Ruthie Ann Miles in The Fantasticks
Photograph: Courtesy Joan MarcusThe Fantasticks

The transformation of The Fantasticks into a same-sex romance could have been effected cosmetically, with jokey winks: In the original, El Gallo says that his name should be pronounced “El Gay-o,” and repeatedly describes one mode of abduction as “new and gay”; he later sings that life is “reckless and terribly gay,” a sentiment he then hits home in counterpoint. ( “Gay— / We're so gay! / Terribly gay!”) But none of those lines have survived the revision. Nor has Jones taken the obvious route of turning the boys’ secret love into a drama about closetedness and parental homophobia. There is only the faintest of feints in that direction: Early on, Matt’s mother announces that she has chosen him a wife, and his defiant lines about “defying Biology” acquire a lavender tint. (“I will not wed by your wisdom,” he declares. “I will not walk neatly into a church and contract out to prolongate my race.”) Otherwise, the fact that both lovers are boys is treated with lovely nonchalance. 

Kevin Del Aguila, David Patrick Kelly, and Ahmad Simmons in The Fantasticks
Photograph: Courtesy Joan MarcusThe Fantasticks

The queering of Cats: The Jellicle Ball was radically loud; this one is radically soft. The theater-folk whimsy of The Fantasticks was never everyone’s cup of tea; Stephen Sondheim hated it, for instance (although its transition into the second—the characters are stuck in a tableau vivant that is broken when one of them says “It’s hot”—is strongly echoed in Sunday in the Park with George). But because we haven’t seen young gay romance depicted this way in the context of a classic American musical, the potential corniness of The Fantasticks is cut with mintier flavors. When Luisa insists that she is a princess and dreams of growing her hair to the ground, she may come off as generic; when Lewis does the same—”I’ve told you. I am blood royal!”—he’s a more specific breed of self-dramatizing queer kid. 

It doesn’t hurt that Maxim Chlumecky and Nathan Levy, as Matt and Lewis, are fresh-faced, strong-voiced and sweet. And Gattelli has surrounded them with super troupers: Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles are a hoot and three quarters as the moms, and David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila are deliciously hammy as a pair of ancient actors roped into playing bandits. (Del Aguila’s character is a specialist in death scenes, and Del Aguila milks them for dear life.) As the Mute, who doubles as the Wall, Ahmad Simmons sidesteps the pitfalls of mime with grace and, as always, the best smile on Broadway. And although the superhero-handsome Zane Phillips lacks the gravitas to pull off El Gallo’s passages of pseudo worldly-wisdom, his baritone voice is surprisingly rich and he has arms that most men would be proud to call legs. 

Ahmad Simmons in The Fantasticks
Photograph: Courtesy Joan MarcusThe Fantasticks

And of course, there is the score, whose highlights include “Try to Remember,” “Soon It’s Gonna Rain” and the proto–Pippinish “I Can See It,” sung here with old-fashioned fullness and supported by Sam Davis's orchestrations, thoughtfully expanded for an eight-piece band. The Helen Hayes Theater is Broadway’s smallest house, and when The Fantasticks is at its best, it feels even smaller. 

The Fantasticks. Helen Hayes Theater (Broadway). Book and lyrics by Tom Jones. Music by Harvey Schmidt. Directed by Christopher Gattelli. With Maxim Chlumecky, Nathan Levy, Zane Phillips, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Ruthie Ann Miles, David Patrick Kelly, Kevin Del Aguila, Ahmad Simmons. 2hrs 10mins. One intermission.

Follow Adam Feldman on X: @FeldmanAdam
Follow Adam Feldman on Bluesky: @FeldmanAdam
Follow Adam Feldman on Threads: @adfeldman
Watch Time Out’s theater podcast on YouTube: Sitting Ovations
Follow Time Out Theater on X: @TimeOutTheater
Keep up with the latest news and reviews on our Time Out Theater Facebook page

Nathan Levy, Ahmad Simmons, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer, Zane Phillips, Ruthie Ann Miles, Maxim Chlumecky in The Fantasticks
Photograph: Courtesy Joan MarcusThe Fantasticks

Popular on Time Out

    Latest news
      Advertising