Get us in your inbox

NYC street sidewalk crowd
Photograph: Shutterstock

Eight ways to tell a real New Yorker from a fake New Yorker

Written by
Jonathan Millstein

NYC is a city of transplants, interns and tourists with a few born-and-bred New Yorkers mixed into the bunch. Regardless of which category you fall into here are eight telltale ways to tell a real New Yorker from a fake New Yorker. 

RECOMMENDED: 16 ways you know someone is an NYC newbie, according to New Yorkers

1. Real New Yorkers will sit by the rail at all costs.

Sure, it's a little weird sliding down into that warm seat once someone gets up, but it's a small price to pay for the freedom the rail provides. And if you catch an empty train, all the better, kickback against the rail and relax.

walk sign
Photograph: Shutterstock

2. Fake New Yorkers will wait for the walk sign.

Is there an explosion of jaywalking tickets being handed out everywhere else in this country? Seriously, why is it so taboo to not just use common sense and cross when it's clear everywhere else?  

Photography: Wendy Connett

3. Fake New Yorkers are still offered mixtapes in Times Square.

A real New Yorker will walk right past free of harassment, but a fake New Yorker will be sensed and handed a mixtape. Never take the mixtape. 

Photograph: Paul Wagtouicz

4. Real New Yorkers will have a strong opinion about the city's best burger.  

Whether a chain like Five Guys or Shake Shack or a New York institution like Minetta Tavern you need to have a strong enough opinion that you're willing to fight with your friends. 

food carts
Photograph: Shutterstock

5. Fake New Yorkers won't eat from food carts.  

It may seem dirty to an outsider, but these hot dog and halal carts are providing on-the-go meals to real New Yorkers. 

Photograph: Navid Baraty

6. Real New Yorkers will give an intersection, not an address. 

A numbered address is akin to hieroglyphics. Give a person the intersection and then it's up to them to figure it out. 

Photograph: Peter Mauss Esto Photography

7. Real New Yorkers won't wait in line for instafamous food.

The nice thing about New York is no matter if you want a bagel, burger or salad there are multiple great options within the city. We don't wait in line for some instafamous spot. 

Photograph: iStockphoto

8. Real New Yorkers will just walk  

Twenty blocks may seem like a marathon to out-of-towners, but years of building up an impressive walking tolerance (and speed) mean we sometimes get there even faster than taking a taxi or Uber. 

Love doing stuff in your city? Tell us all about it in our annual, global, Time Out Index survey

Popular on Time Out

    More on city identity

      Latest news


        The best things in life are free.

        Get our free newsletter – it’s great.

        Loading animation
        Déjà vu! We already have this email. Try another?

        🙌 Awesome, you're subscribed!

        Thanks for subscribing! Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon!