Braised lamb neck at the Marrow
Brandy old fashioned at the Butterfly
Chopped steak at the Butterfly
Beurre Sel Cookies
Canoli at Krescendo
Pasta with fennel, sardines and pine nuts at Krescendo
Pasta chitarra al nero at Krescendo
Sausage, fennel, ricotta and provolone pizza at Krescendo
Escargot-and-marrow tart at M. Wells Dinette
Caviar, whipped butter and flowers on rye at M. Wells Dinette
Egg flan and foie at M. Wells Dinette
Cod and endive salad at Manzanilla
Anchovies on toast at Manzanilla
Tahona Smash and One Flight Up at Pouring Ribbons
Vegetables at Red Gravy
Bucatini al sarde (sardines and fennel) at Red Gravy
Waymaker (right) at Red Gravy
Porgy in a spicy fish broth at Red Gravy
Roasted pork shoulder at Red Gravy
Roasted potatoes at Red Gravy
Remember the Maine cocktail at The Library at the Public Theater
Mussels at the Library at the Public Theater
Every year, buzzed-about new NYC restaurants open their doors, offering diners a fresh collection of dishes and drinks to explore. Here are our picks for the hottest openings of new NYC restaurants and bars—including top spots for Southern Italian plates, modern Spanish fare and craft cocktails—this fall.
RECOMMENDED: Full list of NYC restaurants opening this fall
Beurre & Sel
For several years now, beloved cookbook author, blogger and baking maven Dorie Greenspan and son Josh have been thrilling sugar fiends with their pop-up CookieBar. Come September, the mother-and-son duo will (finally) open a pair of year-round bakeshops showcasing Greenspan’s elegant treats: classic French vanilla sablés (shortbread), blueberry jammers topped with streusel, and her signature World Peace Cookies (Valrhona cocoa and extra-bitter chocolate with Guérande fleur de sel). 1590 Park Ave between 112th and 115th Sts • 120 Essex St between Delancey and Rivington Sts • (no phone yet, beurreandsel.com). Early September.
Buzzy West Coast imports have been storming New York lately (see Mission Chinese Food, Pok Pok Ny). In September, you can add the new pizzeria from Top Chef Masters contestant Elizabeth Falkner to the list. Brought on to the project by owner and fellow Californian restaurateur Nancy Puglisi (Tony’s Pizza Napoletana), the SF pastry rock star will add wood-fired pizzas (such as a Margherita) and homemade pastas (like one with sardines, wild fennel, pine nuts and raisins) to her repertoire of doughy delights. Of course, there will be desserts, too—traditional treats such as tartufo and tiramisu. Another San Francisco transplant, bar manager Darren Crawford of Bourbon & Branch, will see to Italian-inflected cocktails behind the oak bar. 364 Atlantic Ave between Bond and Hoyt Sts, Boerum Hill, Brooklyn (718-330-0888). Mid-September.
M. Wells Dinette
Madcap Quebecois chef Hugue Dufour and wife Sarah Obraitis—whose cultish diner, M. Wells, shuttered last year—will make their triumphant return with this boundary-pushing museum cafeteria at MoMA PS1. Don’t expect pallid plastic-wrapped sandwiches: Dufour will dish out twists on French classics (egg in aspic, steak tartare) and some Asian plates (bibimbap), served in bento boxes or on compartment trays. Also of note: a roe bar—stocked with paddlefish eggs, uni and luxe caviar—will provide the makings for inventive items like a caviar-and-whipped-butter sandwich with edible flowers on rye. Inspired by the art institution’s elementary-school past, the space will feature hanging maps and cubbyhole communal tables styled after school desks. 22-25 Jackson Ave at 46th Ave, Long Island City, Queens (no phone yet). Mid-September.
The hotshot cocktail team behind Alchemy Consulting—Toby Maloney, Jason Cott, Troy Sidle and Death & Company vet Joaquín Simó—have opened trailblazing bars in Chicago (the Violet Hour), Nashville (the Patterson House, the Catbird Seat) and Minneapolis (Bradstreet Craftshouse). But this drinkery will mark their first solo project in New York. The second-floor spot is lit by Art Deco glass shafts and a large arched window spanning the front of the bar. Grab a seat to sample a cocktail menu composed of classic and original tipples, such as the One Flight Up, an egg-white drink made with pisco brandy, blanc vermouth, lemon juice and Campari. 225 Ave B between 13th and 14th Sts (917-656-6788). Mid-September.
Having celebrated Italy’s fertile Emilia-Romagna region with Osteria Morini and the Boot’s coastal cuisine with Marea, Michael White now casts an eye back toward his native Wisconsin for his latest venture, the Butterfly, named after a Midwestern restaurant where the chef worked as a Beloit youth. The retro supper club will spotlight American-hometown revisions of classics like spaghetti and meatballs and chopped steak. Drinks come from masterly barman Eben Freeman, who plans to offer spins on midcentury tipples like the crème de menthe–based grasshopper and a brandy old-fashioned. His podium: a 21-foot-long bar with a woodcut back wall that resembles the open wings of a butterfly. 225 West Broadway at White St (no phone yet). Late September.
The Library at the Public Theater
In the landmarked building that houses the Public Theater, white-hot chef Andrew Carmellini stages his third, much-anticipated act: a preshow lounge. The Café Boulud alum—whose holdings include the Dutch and Locanda Verde—will offer a menu influenced by New York's dining culture. Pair his dishes—mussels in a garlicky red sauce, seafood gumbo with andouille sausage—with a classic cocktail. Make some time to wander the room: Designed by David Rockwell and modeled after Gotham’s first public library (the building’s original inhabitant), it features an elaborate Parisian rug and industrial steel-frame bookcases along the walls. Also keep your eyes peeled for Carmellini's return to his classical culinary roots when his as-yet–unnamed French-inflected project opens nearby (at 380 Lafayette Street) towards the end of the year. 425 Lafayette St between Astor Pl and E 4th St (212-539-8777). Early October.
Saul Bolton—the Michelin-starred Brooklyn toque behind Saul, the Vanderbilt and cocktail bar Botanica—sets his sights on Southern Italy with this 75-seat trattoria. Homemade pasta and whole butchered animals will form the foundation of Bolton’s seasonal Italian menu. To drink, find homemade amari, vermouth and limoncello, plus a wine list highlighting small-production bottles from the lower part of the Boot. 151 Atlantic Ave between Clinton and Henry Sts, Brooklyn Heights (no phone yet). Late October.
Spanish chef Dani Garcia—who racked up two Michelin stars for his inventive restaurant Calima in Marbella, Spain—joins forces with Boqueria restaurateur Yann de Rochefort to open Manzanilla. This bi-level spot, conceived as a “Spanish brasserie” and decked out with herringbone-pattern tiled floors and wood ceilings, will offer whimsical takes on traditional mains, influenced by Garcia’s native Andalusia. Anticipate glazed black cod with caramelized piquillo peppers and bomba rice cooked in squid ink with monkfish, prawns and cuttlefish. 345 Park Ave South between 25th and 26th Sts (no phone yet). Mid-November.
Season-one Top Chef champ Harold Dieterle—who garnered serious acclaim with his West Village Thai eatery, Kin Shop—will salute his family heritage at this meatcentric Italian and Germanic venture. Feast on braised brisket braciola and ostrich schnitzel in the bright 61-seat dining room, which offers a view of the kitchen. An extensive, 70-plus-bottle wine program will focus on German and Austrian whites and Italian reds. 99 Bank St between Greenwich and Hudson Sts (no phone yet). Mid-November.
Torrisi project (name TBD)
Food-world pied pipers Rich Torrisi and Mario Carbone (Torrisi Italian Specialties, Parm) continue their campaign to reinvigorate stale Italian-American staples at their third venture, which will harken back to the red-sauce restaurants of midcentury New York. Branching out beyond Nolita, they’ve stationed the new eatery in the historic Rocco Restaurant space, a Greenwich Village staple since 1922. 181 Thompson St between Bleecker and W Houston Sts (no phone yet). Mid-November.
Ted’s Montana Grill
The only New York outpost of the bison-centric restaurant chain is in Midtown, and adventurous meat-eaters flock from all over the city to taste the lean protein. It’s not all bison burgers, either—though you could certainly sample one with bacon and cheddar ($21) or another with gruyere, blue cheese, caramelized onions and arugula ($22). Sample the bison nachos with pepper jack cheese ($12), dabble in the barbecue bison short ribs ($26) or go all out with the aged bison filet ($40). Of course, there are also plenty of bison-free options, like the cedar plank salmon ($28) or the beer-glazed roasted half chicken with garlic mashed potatoes ($23). Ted’s Montana Grill also offers a full beer and wine menu, plus several signature cocktails. You may still be in the big city, but you’ll certainly get a taste of Big Sky Country.
Venue says: “Voted winner in the Time Out Love New York Award 2016! Come enjoy our delicious, made-from-scratch, Authentic American cuisine”