Time Out says
Willy Wonka's chocolate wonderland is open in Sydney – but a bit more pure imagination might help
Roald Dahl’s Charlie and the Chocolate Factory has a bit of a chequered past as a stage musical. It opened in a huge, lavish production on London’s West End in 2013, and although sheer spectacle helped it run three years, it wasn’t exactly a smash hit, and reviews were lukewarm.
In 2017, the show was given a brand new production for Broadway, which got some things right – it added more songs from the 1971 film to the new score by Scott Wittman and Marc Shaiman – but was savaged by a bunch of critics for its apparently uninspired score, scenes and underwhelming staging. It closed after just nine months, which is a pretty damning indictment on a musical based on such a popular family-friendly story.
But that hasn’t stopped Australian producers bringing the show to our shores in this production by director Jack O’Brien, based on his own Broadway production.
It’s certainly not the charmless disaster those scathing Broadway reviews would have you believe – O’Brien and the Australian company have nailed some of the comedic elements and created a show that generously reaches out to its audience and keeps them totally entertained.
But they can’t quite overcome the problems in the show itself. Things get off to a shaky start when the curtain rises on mysterious chocolatier Willy Wonka (Paul Slade Smith), who tells the audience about his mission – he’s going to disguise himself as a chocolate seller and find an appropriate heir to his candy fortune. He meets Charlie near immediately and hatches the famous golden ticket plan. We all know exactly how this will play out – not because we’ve read the book or seen the film(s) but because Charlie and Wonka have a connection from the show’s first scene. Mystery? Tension? Surprise? Not so much.
The first act – which all takes place before anybody sets foot inside the factory – is powered by the charm of Tony Sheldon as Grandpa Joe and, on opening night, the excellent 13-year-old Ryan Yeates as Charlie. It takes its time to set up the narrative, and each of the four other golden ticket winners – ghastly children, updated for the 21st century and played with glee by adults – are introduced with a pastiche song. While Augustus (Jake Fehily) and Mrs Gloop (Octavia Barron Martin) get a surprisingly sweet and funny German beer hall-inspired tune called ‘More of Him to Love’, Violet (Monette McKay) and Mr Beauregard’s (Madison McKoy) poptastic ‘Queen of Pop’ doesn’t really go anywhere.
The second act has considerably more laughs and thrills as the children are knocked off, one-by-one, in appropriately grisly ways. But things never quite soar – not when we’re first introduced to the factory in ‘Pure Imagination’, nor when the great glass elevator flies over the city.
The cast work incredibly hard to bring a touch of magic and there are several standouts: Karina Russell’s Veruca Salt is a ballet-dancing brattish nightmare, and it’s a shame that Augustus is the first kid to be knocked off, as you want much more of Jake Fehily and Octavia Barron Martin’s joyful Mrs Gloop. Paul Slade Smith sings the role of Wonka well, brings bucketloads of whimsy and keeps things on track. But there’s something maybe a little too safe about his approach – Wonka’s eccentricities feel too controlled and calculated.
And perhaps it’s appropriate that a central tenet of the story is the power of imagination given the paucity of magic in designer Mark Thompson’s scaled-back set; you’ll have to use your own mind’s eye to fill in some gaps. That’s not to say it’s an unattractive show – the video projections help set the scene with colour and wit and the costumes all reveal plenty about the characters – but audiences should get a little more visual bang for their buck in this sort of show. It really should look like the chocolate factory of your dreams. It’s disappointing that Sydney should get a touring version rather than the whole shebang – it’s already booking through to May and is a clear box office hit.
At least the Oompa Loompas are wonderful, rendered here as a chorus line of all-singing, all-dancing puppets played with utter precision and joy by the ensemble. To tell you exactly how they look or work would spoil one of the show’s most delightful moments. It’s just a shame that the show itself – a surefire sugar rush with blissfully little nutritional value – doesn’t have a few more of these surprises.
Users say (5)
Average User Rating
2.2 / 5
- 5 star:1
- 4 star:0
- 3 star:0
- 2 star:2
- 1 star:2
This review is pretty spot-on and definitely more accurate than some very generous reviews found elsewhere. For die-hard Wonka fans and those who rarely go to the theatre (such as my date for the evening who got into it a bit too much!), it’s a good night out but for those of us who regularly attend the big musicals it was a big disappointment. The original songs lacked any kind of melody and were instantly forgettable, the sets were low budget and Wonka himself lacked some of that eccentricity that we loved with Wilder and, perhaps a lesser extent, Depp.
One of the reasons why the Disney musicals are so successful is because of the huge production value and the fact they stay true to the original story but from the opening scene here you realise that there’s a deviation which immediately makes you feel uncomfortable. I would have preferred Bucket’s family to retain the English accents instead of the Aussie twang, the father to be present and Veruca Salt to be the familiar English brat instead of a ballet dancing daughter of a oligarch-like Russian billionaire.
There were a few positives such as the nut cracking squirrels and the Oompa Loompas which by far received the biggest cheer of the night but it was otherwise very flat and uninspiring. If you are someone that buys the premium tickets such as myself I would suggest saving your money and if you really feel the need to go, maybe go for the less expensive seats.
DON'T TAKE YOUNG CHILDREN TO THIS SHOW YOU WILL BE WASTING YOUR MONEY.
We took our grandchildren aged 6 and 12.
The 6 years old was bored about a quarter of the way through the first half and it wasn't much better for him in the 2nd half. The only thing he liked in the show was the Oompah Loompas.
The 12 year old said she enjoyed it but I think she was being polite.
This is really NOT a musical to take children to. Very disappointing not worth the money or the 3 hr trip to see it.
Absolutely rubbish I am looking for others to start class action to retrieve money back only 30% capacity on Saturday kids falling asleep most leaving during intermission or before just pushing highly inflated merchandise shame shame shame disgusted to the max don’t go REPEAT DONT GO
This review bu Dave K is spot on. We made a whole family Sydney trip for this show. Had a great time in Sydney, but the show is exactly what Dave K above states.
My 2 daughters have never once ever mentioned this show again. The music was totally forgettable and the sets were a joke. We paid $250+ for each ticket because we don't do this often, but unfortunately we chose the wrong show to spend big bucks on... Not recommended for adults, Wonker fans or children for the price
This show was fabulous and fun. I had a smile on my face the whole time and my partner loved it too. We went for my birthday because I love the original movie and couldn't wait to see it live on stage. Willy Wonka was terrific - quirky and fun with plenty about him that reminded me of Gene Wilder.
The Bucket family scenes were charming and the boy who played Charlie was the perfect sweet and well behaved boy. I loved the way they did the Bucket shack and bed.
The wicked golden ticket winners were terrible children - just the way they are meant to be. Veruca I loved to hate and the song by Augustus and his mother was so much fun it had us clapping along.
The special effects were incredible, like the dancing squirrels, Charlie's paper plane letter to Willy Wonka flying over the audience, Violet blowing up in front of our eyes and Mike shrinking to a tiny size to be on TV. I have spent so much time since trying to work out how they did those tricks live on stage!
I thought the chocolate factory garden was spectacular and the big dance numbers terrific. Oh and the oompa loompahs - you will love how they bring them to life. It's a great show and I really want to see it again.