The top ten haunted places in New York City
Don’t be surprised if you run into the ghosts of Edgar Allan Poe and Mark Twain near these haunted places. Okay, fine, be very surprised.
Wed Oct 30 2013
Photograph: Donald Yip
Who you gonna call? Just in time for Halloween, we’ve found the most haunted places in Gotham, from a functioning, allegedly apparition-filled bar to the grisly-sounding Manhattan Murder Well. For more spooks, check out our list of the 100 greatest horror movies ever.
The Tredwell family moved into this then-newish Noho town house in 1835—and some say they never left. It became a museum in 1936, three years after final occupant Gertrude Tredwell died at 93, and visitors have reported seeing and feeling poor Gerty and her seven siblings’ presence ever since.
- 29 E 4th St, (between Bowery and Lafayette St)
2. House of Death
This brownstone residence’s nickname is well earned, as it’s been the setting for a host of mysterious passings. In the book Spindrift: Spray from a Psychic Sea, Jan Bryant Bartell discusses her experience living there, noting that she ran into the spirit of former resident Mark Twain one night in her living room. What’d the novelist tell her? “My name is Clemens, and I has a problem here I gotta settle.” Oh, Twain, hilarious as ever.
- 14 W 10th St between Fifth and Sixth Aves
The spook of founding father and successful duelist Aaron Burr is said to frequent this swanky West Village eatery. Many believe the former Vice President is the source of the paranormal activity—flickering lights, missing items—in the restaurant, which is located in what was once his carriage house.
- 17 Barrow St, (between Seventh Ave South and W 4th St), 10014
4. 85 West 3rd Street
In 1845 and ’46, this location (now an NYU building) was the home of Edgar Allan Poe, who penned parts of his opus “The Raven” there. Only a single banister apparently remains from the original layout, and some have reported spotting Poe near it.
- 85 W 3rd St between Sullivan and Thompson Sts
Legend has it that this Irish tavern, housed in a nearly 200-year-old building, is haunted by a sailor named Mickey. (The seaman was apparently hit by a car and died outside the bar in the 1960s.) He’s said to make his presence known by lighting the fireplace.
- 326 Spring St, (between Greenwich and Washington Sts), 10013
6. Billop House
In the late 1700s, British loyalist Christopher Billop, then the owner of this 1680 stone homestead, allegedly killed a female servant suspected of spying for the Patriots. Both victim and murderer are said to haunt the premises, along with the apparitions of patrolling redcoats. 718-984-6046, conferencehouse.org
- 298 Satterlee St between Craig Ave and Hylan Blvd, Staten Island
This famed cultural hot spot was built over a mass burial ground, where as many as 20,000 bodies, including
victims of the 19th-century yellow-fever epidemic, resided. And if Poltergeist taught us anything, it’s that you do
not develop on top of the dead.
- W 4th St to Waverly Pl, (between MacDougal St and University Pl)
Locals claim that this place of worship is a hotbed for ghosts, including that of Peter Stuyvesant, whose remains are buried in the churchyard. (He probably wants to make sure you haven’t forgotten about him since your second-grade unit on New Amsterdam ended.)
- 131 E 10th St, (at Second Ave)
This artists’ hangout is well-known for providing lodging to rock stars and cultural celebrities over the years. And according to believers, a few residents (like Sid Vicious’s girlfriend, Nancy Spungen, who was found stabbed in the couple’s bathroom, and Dylan Thomas, who died at nearby St. Vincent’s Hospital) may have never checked out. Closed for renovations.
- 222 W 23rd St, (between Seventh and Eighth Aves), 10011
10. Manhattan Murder Well
In 1799, the slain body of Gulielma Elmore Sands was discovered in a well just north of Spring Street. (Her suitor, Levi Weeks, was suspected of the crime but acquitted.) Rumor has it that the well remains intact in the basement of this downtown building, the only remnant of the grisly act—other than, perhaps, Sands’s ghost.
- 129 Spring St between Greene and Wooster Sts
You might also like
What do you think? Tell us below!
Send tips and cat photos to:
Editor: Marley Lynch (@marleyasinbob)