Time Out says
An unassuming Peckham Rye pizza joint.
Pizza Pickup – a pared-back little box of a restaurant on the foodie strip of shops that line the north end of Peckham Rye – is an assuming spot. Its look, with a wall of bare bricks, some faux-retro Italian city posters (Firenze! Roma! And so on) and fake-marble-topped tables is far from hip. Menus are roughly printed. The pies are thin and crisp – no blistering Neapolitan cornicione here – and the toppings basic. It may have started as a street-food van, but artisanal and high concept this is not. The ciao? Fine. No more than that, but certainly passable if you’d rather avoid the 15-minute schlep west to Franco Manca in Dulwich or east to Four Hundred Rabbits in Nunhead.
A focaccia was nothing of the sort. Rather, it was a salted, plain pizza base. Soaked in grassy olive oil it was not. Both the tomatoes and mozzarella in a caprese salad were fridge cold and drizzled with a sweet balsamic syrup. Pizzas were tomato heavy and cheese light, though the meaty toppings on ours – cotto ham and prosciutto – were generous. Tiramisu was a tad cakey and needed more booze. Pizza Pickup is almost retro in its lack of ambition – plus, the most expensive bottle on the wine list is a fizzy red lambrusco, which even they admit is a non-ironic nod to the 80s – which in 2017 is pretty novel in itself.
64 Peckham Rye
|Price:||Dinner for two with drinks and service: around £60.|
|Do you own this business?|
Users say (71)
Average User Rating
4.8 / 5
- 5 star:62
- 4 star:6
- 3 star:0
- 2 star:0
- 1 star:2
Amazing pizza and wonderful service! So happy that they do gluten free bases!!!! And the staff are so lovely and polite! Will be returning for more delicious food very soon! Thanks for a great evening!
I am a huge pizza fan and therefore can be quite picky when it comes to crusts, bases, ingredients etc... and I can honestly say this is the best pizza I’ve eaten in 7 years of living in London.
The ingredients were top quality and fresh, the owner (half roman) is friendly and knowledgeable about the food, as well as the cooking process.
Pizza Pickup is one of the few places in London that has a terracotta lined pizza oven, which I am told is the most authentic way of cooking a true roman pizza. The base is crispy and light and the toppings delicious and obviously chosen with care - I had pepperoni with olives and can highly recommend it.
My boyfriend had the special which was focaccia with mozzarella, tomatoes and pepperoni - also a hit - it tasted clean, fresh and authentic.
The puddings are also out of this world - I can recommend the tiramisu which is by far and away the best one I have EVER had. And we were also pretty happy with the Nutella pizza!
I have read a small hand full of negative reviews on here as well as Thomas Howells rather scathing critique that I can’t believe are the same place - I have nothing bad to say about it! Also, be sure to check out the loo when you’re there, there is a lovely marble sink!!
Amazing pizza at Pizza Pickup! Went to Peckham for a drinks and fancied a bite to eat and we ended up having an amazing meal here. Nick was very friendly & made our night with his service! Would recommend this to anyone who is looking for Romanic style pizza done right!
This place is amazing, delicious authentic Roman pizzas, great vibe and the owner is brilliant, really cares about the quality of pizza.
I don't know how Timeout got this so wrong, maybe they got confused with Voodoo Rays across the road (that place really is god awful), sort yourselves out Timeout and try again!
I don't understand Time Out's poor review about this place! This is by far one of the best pizzerias in the local area! Take this advice from an Italian, this place is great and truly authentic!
Amazing Roman pizza; Time Out review does not know their pizza and I am afraid it shows very poor editorial judgement on behalf of Time Out as well. Some of the best pizza I have been lucky enough to eat in London; please go. Went with partner and two children and had a fantastic time. Quite good beer selection as well, plus kids Pizzas are half price and pretty generous.
Whoever wrote the review of this place for Pizza Pickup is clearly not Italian! Send Italians to Italian places!!! BEST pizza in London in 13 years since I relocated here!! I had them in the most popular pizzerie across the city and no one made it as good. Not Rosso Pomodoro, not Luna Rossa.. None of those promoted wildly as genuine Italian. The place is unpretentious, service fast and staff warm and friendly without being over the top. The dough is amazingly light, the pizza made the Tuscan way: thin crust and rich in toppings.
Time Out needs better food "critics!
I come from a family of restauranteurs, 4 generations from both mom and dad's side: I HIGHLY recommend this place. You'll never regret having tried it. Affordable too, and family friendly.
Go for it, without concerns!
PROPER AUTHENTIC ITALIAN PIZZA! Loved it! Went there quick late totally randomly with a friend visiting and we had the best pizza in a long time. The cosy and warm atmosphere caught our eyes. Service was really really quick and the staff (waitress, chef, manager) was super nice. Also loved the drinks suggestions made by Nick the owner. Got a bit tipsy and even happier! :) Will definitely recommend and give it a try during summer time as the restaurant is located close to the park! Thanks for the night <3
Think you should send someone else from TimeOut to review this please because I don't know what he's talking about? After coming back from Rome, this pizza was exactly how the Romans do it. If you're looking for Neapolitan style (which I think has been over done now, so this is a nice change) then look somewhere else but this pizza I believe is the perfect in between. The friendliest service, the montepulciano red wine, the pizzas and calzones are phenomenal with the fresh ingredients and stone fire pit from Rome. Have been over 15 times and not one complaint.
Echoing what all the other reviews say - the Time Out review is way off base!
The marble is real, the owner is ace, and the pizza is delicious.
Plus, they welcome furry friends, which is always appreciated as a dog owner.
I think they're owed a re-do.
Great food and ambience. The tomato sauce pizza base is the best out of Peckham pizzas for sure. Reasonably priced and friendly service.
Will be returning soon.
what an unfair review! the pizzas at pizza pickup are amazing! they are lovely and crisp, and remind me of holidays in rome. have been several times and the food is always consistently good, and look forward to my next visit
Great Pizza. A different offering to other pizzerias I've visited in the area - Fantastic crispy base. Really friendly service and pretty good value. Will be returning.
Great service, friendly staff, amazing pizza. Have been here a few times now and it never disappoints. Great local pizzeria with really authentic Roman pizzas. Desserts are great too and wine is always lovely as a bonus.
What an unfair review!
We've been several times to Pizza Pickup because we so perfer the thin, crispy pizza to the likes of Franco Manca. Having visited Italy a number of times, this pizza takes me straight back there, it's authentic and covered in delicious topping! What's more is that the owner and his staff are so efficient and friendly- just what you need! If you're after thin and crispy pizza, just like the Italians do, Pizza Pickup is an absolute must; you won't be disappointed.
Completely disagree with the Timeout Review on this place, Pizza Pickup is doing pizza the proper way with its thin base and restaurant setting reminiscent of a proper Roma pizzeria. The staff are friendly, the atmosphere is relaxed and the pizzas are super tasty. A great addition to the Peckham high street!!
Time out, as usual, searching to find food vendors that fit their sterile mould of 'artisanal' and 'high concept' restraraunts. The end-product Roma pizza at Pizza Pickup is miles ahead of local competitors Voodoo Rays (which Time Out have described as 'impeccably hip') in quality and taste, the service was great and the staff (we were served by Nic) were friendly and knew their stuff. Will definitely be eating their Pizza again!
I get pizzas from Pizza Pick Up quite often, both take away and eat in, and I think they are the best pizzas in our next of the woods. The crust is excellent, the toppings are really tasty, the atmosphere is really nice and casual, unlike some of the local alternatives (one in particular where it is a nightmare working out the byzantine ordering system). Would thoroughly recommend it for anyone looking for a take away or eat in pizza in or around Peckham.
I ate at Pizza Pickup last weekend and was pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere was great, the restaurant clean, and food amazing!!! The time Out review was simply cruel and as someone described it, ‘snobbery’ I am so pleased and may I say, proud to have the ‘Pizza Pickup’ restaurant so close by, I know where I’ll be going for my pizza fix from now on. The Focaccia bread was not a ‘crispy pizza base’ as described by the Time Out review, it was indeed a crispy Focaccia bread!!! and may I say, scrumptious. Having heard the history and hard work put in to the restaurant by the owners and it’s development, this makes you appreciate it even more. Picking holes in ‘wall signs and table tops’ is plain daft and serves no purpose. Well done, great place to eat, and very reasonably priced.
Great pizza, thin crispy base, fresh tomato sauce and classic toppings. And a very nice place to spend half an hour. Food was quick and hot and service was great. 😚👌🏼
Ate here on Saturday night - Time Out review is nonsense. No, I'm not italian and don't know how a Rome pizza should truly taste, but I've eaten at just about every pizza place in London and would therefore like to consider myself well-placed to judge. The foccacia and Pepperoni pizza i had were genuinely delicious and i defy anyone to say otherwise. And the atmosphere and the staff are great. What more could you ask for from a pizza restaurant?
Pizza Pickup is a small, or indeed large slice, of delightful atmosphere and service. The review offered by Time Out frankly reeks of a snobbery so boring that it comes across as a parody of themselves.
Great pizza!!! Great service. Seriously great.
Weird time out review...if the reviewer needs to be distracted by flashy decor to enjoy his food then he may need to check his attention span... and maybe check out a few authentic trattorias on his next trip to italy.
I did think Time Out was always a reliable source of impartial reviewing but how wrong could they be.
Clearly the reviewer had been tapped up by another outlet to give such a poor review. Not real marble! WTF
Really very good pizza best I've eaten outside Italy.
Go eat local and support a top local pizzeria
Make no mistake - this is a great pizza place if you look authentic Roman pizza. No stodgy thick bases loaded with cheap melted cheese here. Friendly and informative service by the owner who clearly had been sadly affected by the poor and underserved 2star rating by Time Out. Give this place a go - we liked it a lot.
I think the Time Out reviewer needs to take a moment and return, with a decent night of sleep beforehand, as his two star review doesn't make sense. I went to Pizza Pickup last week with some friends who live in Clapham after hearing about it. I live in Fulham.
The pizzas were simple and delicious. I rarely eat the crusts but all of our plates went back completely clean, which is something I noticed about the other plates going back from other tables. I had the garlic focaccia and it could not have tasted better...and the bread was exactly in type as I've had when in Rome. Re: the Time Out review of the focaccia, focaccia is a flat bread and comes in different thicknesses. It was exactly as I had hoped for.
What was great that there was no bloaty feeling after eating the pizza, leaving room to try the home made Tiramisu. I couldn't finish the portion, but wish I had the room to as it was also delicious. One of my friends had the 'pizza cioccolato' that had Nutella and sea salt on. Well done whoever invented that!
All in, excellent and defo a five star from me. This is the sort of place I would travel to and I will certainly be back again, but I have asked the owner if he could please open a Pizza Pickup in Fulham to make returning a bit easier!
By the way, the marble is very much real.
Great local pizzeria. Tasty thin authentic pizzas and friendly staff. Refreshingly unpretentious will definitely be returning.
the thin roman pizza at pizza pickup is perfection! not stodgy and a pleasure to eat with excellent choice of toppings to experience an authentic roman pizza. this is made even better by the the friendly and attentive staff. the owner and chefs are italian themselves!
they even offer pizza and beer for a tenner on monday tuesday and wednesday!! brilliant!
Had pizza at this laid back joint last week - One of the BEST pizzas I've ever tasted - second only to what I ate in ROME. . . . Wow - this pizza is worth travelling for. Ignore the rubbish that Timeout has written - who gives a F if the table is marble (they are real marble BTW) - who gives a F if the posters are fauxretro (what does that even mean?! - and they are from the 1940s . . .google) Who gives a F if the place is small - good - this means the really nice staff can focus on the customers. My group had a great time and the pizza is EXCELLENT - one of the best in London. I'll be telling my friends and coming back and back. Shame Timeout got it so wrong - I won't be relying on them as much as I used to . . .
We had a great time a Pizza Pickup Saturday night! Delicious food and refreshingly unpretentious environment. If for some bizarre reason you are turned off by fake marble tables, rest assured they are not fake, they are real marble tables. The service was great and there was a real genuine enthusiasm for creating authentic Rome style pizza. Overall highly recommend!
Pizza Pickup is perfection! The vibe was relaxed and friendly; quaint and homely. Plus the pizza (not really mentioned very much here Timeout) was GREAT! I would definitely recommend you try this gem of a place! On a Saturday night, when every where else is packed, get yourself down to Pizza Pickup. We were pleasantly surprised by how perfect it was. Thank you!
The pizza pickup is incredible! The atmosphere is chilled and friendly. The pizza is tasty and traditional Roma pizza! I feel the time out review was done by someone who doesn't know good food but thinks they're very cool. I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who loves pizza :) x x x Hannah
Oh do chill out a bit, Time Out. I don't always want a massive sourdough crust served on a breadcrumby table by a topknotted hipster anxious to hurry me up and get me out so they can seat some more of the shivering masses queuing outside! Sometimes all I want is friendly service, crispy crusts, generous toppings, decent prices and time and space to sit back and have another beer once I'm done. It's comfort food, lighten up and enjoy it. Goodness me.
(Also I'm afraid I did think the table tops were fake but didn't massively care.)
Snap up exclusive discounts in London
Time Out's handpicked deals — hurry, they won't be around for long...