This is how Rupert Goold’s golden age running the Almeida ends then: not with a bang but with a curio. His final piece of programming sees rising star Ebeneezer Bamgboye direct an overwrought Southern Gothic take on Eugene O’Neill’s 1924 play Desire Under the Elms that is, perhaps perversely saved by an even more overwrought Southern Gothic performance from Kelly Gough.
She’s the younger sister of Andor star Denise Gough, who actually played the role of restless farmer’s wife Abbie in the only other London revival this century, at the Lyric Hammersmith in 2012. Whether Gough Jnr has been sitting on the idea for her take since then or if this is all a massive coincidence, it’s a truly singular interpretation, in the first half especially.
Abbie is decades younger than her husband: coarse, granite-hard farmer Ephraim (Anthony Byrne). He’s is basically a monster who has long suggested he doesn’t want his sons to inherit the farm: Abbie’s arrival persuades Ephriam’s two eldest sons to fly the nest, encouraged by their younger half-brother Eben (Zachary Momoh) who nurses a towering grudge against Ephraim: to his mind his father worked his mother to death and stole the land the farm is on, which belonged to her family.
There is an initial, sexually charged hostility between Eben and Abigail - he describes her in supernaturally evil terms. And it’s not really surprising. Styled and dressed in what is surely an anachronistic costume of tight, sleeveless leather top, pleated black trousers, black DMs and unnatural coppery hair, she comes across as an otherworldly figure, especially as she constantly contorts her body into unnatural shapes and bellows at Eben in truly terrifying, uninhibited fashion when he slopes off to sleep with the local prostitute.
What the hell is going on here? It’s a weakness of Bamgboye’s production that the answer to this question is rarely clear. But at the same time it’s obvious he’s leaning into the supernatural stuff that’s in O’Neill’s play – in particular there’s a moment where Eben is convinced he’s being contacted by the ghost of his mother that the director really embraces. It’s set in 1850, a couple of centuries after the events of The Crucible, but still an unsettled, superstitious frontier America. A trio of on-stage musicians are credited as ‘spirits’. Gough’s Abbie may not be a real witch, but she is certainly fantastically, magnetically, hypnotically other. And the supernatural vibes make for a cool ambiance generally: the christening party for Abigail’s baby – which Ephraim thinks is his, but is in fact Eben’s – is an infernally stylish cascade of distorted beats and angry drunkenness.
Aside from Gough’s overwhelming performance there are nice turns from Momoh as the obsessive Eben and Byne as the simultaneously pitiable and terrifying Ephraim.
Ultimately, though, I think Bamgboye feels overwhelmed by the Almeida and by this play. Much of the first half feels indebted to former Almeida deputy Rebecca Frecknall, all minimalist staging and moody lighting accentuated by constant music. But there’s not the warmth or clarity of character that Frecknall brings to the table. And hypnotic as Gough is, her interpretation makes less obvious sense in the second half, when Abbie’s more conventional human frailties are exposed: if she was the roaring elemental being of the first half, you have to think the play wouldn’t go down the way it does. There’s also some fiddly choreography from Rose Ryan that often feels like it’s muddying the meaning of relatively simple encounters.
A fascinating but fussy and ultimately slightly misguided take on a rarely performed classic that worked better when Gough Snr starred. But like Goold’s whole Almeida tenure: it was never boring.

