Four Play

Theatre, Fringe
3 out of 5 stars

Time Out says

3 out of 5 stars

Friendly warning! We're working hard to be accurate. But these are unusual times, so please check that events are still happening.

An odd mix of the insightful and the smutty in this gay relationship comedy

'Four Play' is on at Above the Stag in January 2020, with a new cast. This review is from 2016.

Pete and Rafe have a problem: they’ve been together for seven years, and all they know is each other. So to give their relationship a shot in the arm, they decide to find someone else they can sleep with – separately. It needs to be someone they trust, but don’t know too well. (Or as Rafe puts it: ‘Not someone we might bump into in Sainsbury’s or catch HIV from.’) So they enlist the services of up-for-it Michael (currently in an open relationship with Andrew). 

Naturally, Pete and Rafe’s scheme awakens far more issues than it resolves. Andrew is at first detachedly amused by Michael’s arrangement – then his voicemails to his boyfriend become increasingly clingy. By this point, the sparks flying between Michael and Pete suggest something beyond no-strings experimentation. And as the play progresses to a toe-curling showdown over dinner, we realise that neither couple is as content as first might seem. 

What emerges is a reflection on monogamy and commitment, and how they co-exist in the twenty-first century. It seems ironic that Jake Brunger was originally commissioned to write a ‘state of the nation gay play’, since these are themes that will resonate across all orientations. What’s harder is squaring the serious stuff against the nudge-wink naughtiness that characterises the rest of it (the title’s innuendo being a good indication). And an over-reliance on twee middle-class anxieties – house prices outside London, the dangers of re-heating prawns – becomes irksome.

 But while it’s played for easy laughs in places, ‘Four Play’ is hard to bear a grudge against. Peter Hannah stands out as the conflicted, self-loathing Michael, and Cecilia Carey’s set accommodates the fast-changing scenes. Too serious to be trivial, and too silly to be hard-hitting, it’s always entertaining. 

By: Matt Breen



You may also like